ArtHitParade
ArtHitParade on X
  • Home
    • Contact
  • Calendar
  • Top 10
    • Origin
    • From 600 BCE to CE
    • Years 1 to 1000
    • Years 1000 to 1400
    • 15th Century >
      • Years 1400-1429
      • Years 1430-1459
      • Years 1460-1479
      • Years 1480-1499
    • 16th Century >
      • Years 1500-1519
      • Decade 1520-1529
      • Decade 1530-1539
      • Years 1540-1569
      • Years 1570-1599
    • 17th Century >
      • Decade 1600-1609
      • Decade 1610-1619
      • Decade 1620-1629
      • Decade 1630-1639
      • Decade 1640-1649
      • Decade 1650-1659
      • Years 1660-1679
      • Years 1680-1699
    • 18th Century >
      • Decade 1700-1709
      • Decade 1710-1719
      • Decade 1720-1729
      • Decade 1730-1739
      • Decade 1740-1749
      • Decade 1750-1759
      • Decade 1760-1769
      • Decade 1770-1779 >
        • 1776
      • Decade 1780-1789 >
        • 1787
      • Decade 1790-1799 >
        • 1792
    • 19th Century >
      • Decade 1800-1809
      • Decade 1810-1819
      • Decade 1820-1829
      • Decade 1830-1839
      • Decade 1840-1849
      • Decade 1850-1859
      • Decade 1860-1869
      • Decade 1870-1879 >
        • 1877
        • 1878
        • 1879
      • Decade 1880-1889 >
        • 1880
        • 1881
        • 1882
        • 1883
        • 1884
        • 1885
        • 1886
        • 1887
        • 1888
        • 1889
      • Decade 1890-1899 >
        • 1890
        • 1891
        • 1892
        • 1893
        • 1894
        • 1895
        • 1896
        • 1897 1898 >
          • 1897
        • 1899 1900 >
          • 1899
    • 20th Century >
      • Decade 1900-1909 >
        • 1901
        • 1902
        • 1903
        • 1904
        • 1905
        • 1906
        • 1907
        • 1908
        • 1909
      • Decade 1910-1919 >
        • 1910
        • 1911
        • 1912
        • 1913
        • 1914
        • 1915
        • 1916
        • 1917
        • 1918
        • 1919
      • Decade 1920-1929 >
        • 1920
        • 1921
        • 1922
        • 1923
        • 1924
        • 1925
        • 1926
        • 1927
        • 1928
        • 1929
      • Decade 1930-1939 >
        • 1930
        • 1931
        • 1932
        • 1933
        • 1934
        • 1935
        • 1936
        • 1937
        • 1938
        • 1939
      • Decade 1940-1949 >
        • 1940
        • 1941
        • 1942
        • 1943
        • 1944
        • 1945
        • 1946
        • 1947
        • 1948
        • 1949
      • Decade 1950-1959 >
        • 1950
        • 1951
        • 1952
        • 1953
        • 1954
        • 1955
        • 1956
        • 1957
        • 1958
        • 1959
      • Decade 1960-1969 >
        • 1960
        • 1961
        • 1962
        • 1963
        • 1964
        • 1965
        • 1966
        • 1967
        • 1968
        • 1969
      • Decade 1970-1979 >
        • 1970
        • 1971
        • 1972
        • 1973
        • 1974
        • 1975
        • 1976
        • 1977
        • 1978
        • 1979
      • Decade 1980-1989 >
        • 1980
        • 1981
        • 1982
        • 1983
        • 1984
        • 1985
        • 1986
        • 1987
        • 1988
        • 1989
      • Decade 1990-1999 >
        • 1990
        • 1991
        • 1992
        • 1993
        • 1994
        • 1995
        • 1996
        • 1997
        • 1998
        • 1999
    • 21st Century >
      • Decade 2000-2009 >
        • 2000
        • 2001
        • 2002
        • 2003
        • 2004
        • 2005
        • 2006
        • 2007
        • 2008
        • 2009
      • Decade 2010-2019 >
        • 2010
        • 2011
        • 2012
        • 2013
        • 2014
        • 2015
        • 2016
        • 2017
        • 2018
        • 2019
      • 2020 to now >
        • 2020
        • 2021
        • 2022
        • 2023 to now >
          • 2024
  • Ancient Painting
    • Flemish Art >
      • Pieter II Brueghel
      • Jan Brueghel
    • Rubens
    • Rembrandt
    • Early Still Life
    • Oil on Copper
  • 18th Century Painting
  • Ancient Drawing
  • Art on Paper
  • Sculpture
    • Bust
    • Ancient Sculpture >
      • Roman Sculpture
    • Italian Sculpture
    • French Sculpture >
      • Rodin
    • Sculpture by Painters
  • Women Artists
    • Ancient Art by Women
    • O'Keeffe
    • Lempicka
    • Martin
    • Mitchell
    • Yayoi Kusama
    • Brown
  • Furniture
    • Chairs and Seats
    • Colonial Furniture
    • Ancient French Furniture
    • Modern Furniture >
      • Art Deco
      • Modern Tables
  • Prints
    • Ancient Prints
    • Modern Prints
  • Photo
    • Old Photos >
      • Travel Photos
      • Early French Photo
    • Photos 1900s 1910s
    • Photos 1920s 1930s
    • Arbus
    • Photos 1970s 1980s
    • Sherman
    • Gursky
  • The Man
  • The Woman
  • Children
  • Man and Woman
  • Groups
  • Self Portrait
    • Self Portrait 2nd page
  • Nude
  • Abstract Art - 2nd page
  • Landscape
  • Cities
    • Venice
    • Paris
  • Flowers
    • Bouquet
  • Animals
    • Bird
    • Cats and Lions
    • Horse
  • Tabletop
  • Music and Dance in Art
    • Music in Old Painting
  • Sport in Art
  • Orientalism
    • Orientalism 1830-1900
  • France
    • French Painting before 1860
    • Pissarro
    • Manet
    • Degas
    • Cézanne
    • Monet >
      • Monet before 1879
      • Monet 1879-1887
      • Series by Monet
      • London and Venice
      • Bassin aux Nymphéas
    • Renoir
    • Caillebotte
    • Gauguin
    • Seurat
    • Signac
    • Lautrec
    • Matisse
    • Léger
    • Klein
    • Lalanne
    • Post War French Art
  • Italy
    • Canaletto
    • Modigliani
    • Fontana
    • Mappa by Boetti
  • Swiss Painting
  • Giacometti
    • Giacometti 1947-53
    • Femme Debout
  • Bacon
    • Bacon before 1963
    • Bacon 1963-70
    • Later Bacons
    • Head Triptych
  • UK - 2nd page
    • Ancient England
    • George III
    • British Royals
    • Turner >
      • Watercolor by Turner
    • Freud >
      • Early Freud
    • Hockney
    • Doig
    • Hirst
    • Banksy
  • Richter
    • Richter before 1983
  • Germany - 2nd page
    • Ancient Germany >
      • Cranach
    • Marc
    • Kirchner
  • Van Gogh
  • Mondrian
  • De Kooning
  • Magritte
    • Early Magritte
  • Belgium 2nd page
  • Ancient Spain
  • Picasso
    • Picasso before 1907
    • Picasso 1907-1931
    • Marie-Thérèse
    • Picasso later 1930s
    • Picasso 1940-1960
    • Picasso in Mougins
    • Prints by Picasso
  • Gris
  • Miro
  • Klimt
  • Schiele
  • USA
    • US Independence
    • Development of USA
    • President Lincoln
    • US Painting before 1940 >
      • Sargent
    • Wild West
    • Hopper
    • Rockwell
    • Calder
    • Rothko >
      • Early Rothko
      • Rothko 1957-70
    • Still
    • Newman
    • Guston
    • Pollock
    • Diebenkorn
    • Lichtenstein >
      • Lichtenstein after 1965
    • Warhol >
      • USA by Warhol
      • Celebrities by Warhol >
        • Elvis and Liz
      • Later Warhols
      • Prints by Warhol >
        • Warhol Prints 2nd page
    • Twombly
    • Johns
    • Ruscha
    • Koons
    • Marshall
    • Wool
    • Basquiat
    • Bradford
  • Central and South Americas
    • Mexico
  • China
    • Ritual Bronzes
    • Song
    • Yuan
    • Ming
    • Early Qing
    • Qianlong
    • Modern China >
      • Qi Baishi
      • Xu Beihong
      • Zhang Daqian >
        • Zhang Daqian before 1965
      • Fu Baoshi
      • Sanyu >
        • Sanyu before 1950
      • Li Keran
      • Wu Guanzhong
      • Zao Wou-Ki
      • Cui Ruzhuo
    • Chinese Porcelain >
      • Song to Yuan Porcelain
      • Ming Porcelain
      • Qing Porcelain
    • Chinese Art
    • Mountains in China
    • Chinese Calligraphy
    • Chinese Furniture
    • Imperial Seal
    • Chinese Dragon
    • Jadeite
  • India
    • Gaitonde
    • Modern India
  • Persia
    • Safavid Carpets
  • Yoshitomo Nara
  • Russia and Eastern Europe
    • Russia 1700-1900
    • Kandinsky
    • Brancusi
    • Chagall
    • Soutine
    • Ghenie
  • Munch
    • Prints by Munch
  • Egypt
  • Tropical Africa
    • Congo
    • Gabon
    • Mask
  • Tribal Oceania
    • Easter Island
  • Australia
    • Colonial Australia
  • Islam
  • Buddhism
    • Early Buddhist Sculpture
    • Tibet and Nepal
  • Judaica
  • Christianity
    • Madonna and Child
  • Cars
    • Birth of Automobile
    • Cars of the 1910s
    • Cars of the 1920s
    • Cars of the 1930s >
      • Cars 1930-33
      • Cars 1934-35
      • Cars 1936-37
      • Cars 1938-39
    • Post War Cars
    • Cars of the 1950s >
      • Cars 1953-54
      • Cars 1955
      • Cars 1956-57
      • Cars 1958-59
    • Cars of the 1960s >
      • Cars 1960-61
      • Cars 1962-63
      • Cars 1964-65
      • Cars 1966-67
    • Cars 1970s 1980s
    • Supercars
    • Hypercars
    • Formula One
    • Ferrari >
      • 250 GT Berlinetta
      • California Spider
      • Big Six
    • Alfa Romeo
    • Maserati
    • Mercedes-Benz
    • Porsche up to 917
    • Porsche after 917
    • Aston Martin
    • Jaguar
    • McLaren
    • Bugatti
    • French Cars >
      • Bugatti Automobiles
    • Duesenberg
    • Ford and Shelby
    • Cars in Movies
  • Motorcycles
  • Jewels
    • White Diamond
    • Pink Diamond
    • Blue Diamond
    • Jewels - 2nd page
    • Cartier
  • Silverware
    • Old Silverware
  • Coin
    • Antique Coins >
      • Roman Coins
    • Coins 1000-1775
    • Coins 1776-92
    • Coins 1793-1819
    • Coins 1820-49
    • Coins 1850-69
    • Coins 1870-99
    • 20th century Coins
    • US Gold Coins
    • Silver Dollar
    • Cent and Dime
    • British Coins
    • Japanese Coins
    • Chinese Coins
  • Paper Currency
  • Medal and Decoration
  • Time Pieces
    • Clocks >
      • Old Clocks
    • Mechanical Craft ca 1800
    • Jaquet-Droz and Followers
    • Modern Watches
    • New Watches >
      • OnlyWatch
    • Patek Philippe >
      • Patek Philippe before 1950
      • World Time
      • Perpetual Calendar
    • Rolex
    • French Time Pieces
    • Daniels
  • Glass and Crystal
    • Glass before 1900
    • Tiffany Studios
  • Terracotta and Porcelain
    • Meissen
  • Textiles
  • Books
    • Incunabula
    • 16th Century Books
    • 17th Century Books
    • Fine Books 1700-1850
    • The Birds of America
  • Literature
    • Literature in French
  • Poems and Lyrics
  • Autograph
  • Manuscript
    • Paleography
    • Illuminated Christian Manuscript
  • Political Document
  • Comic Books
  • Illustration Art
    • Tintin
    • Frazetta
  • Travel
  • Ancient Maps
  • Space
  • Movies
  • Screen Worn
  • Music
  • Musical Instrument
    • Stradivarius
    • Violin 2nd page
    • Guitar
    • Chinese Instrument
  • The Beatles
  • Poster
  • Sport
    • Sport Equipment
    • Sport Document
    • Sport Rewards
    • Sport Cards >
      • Sport Images before 1942
      • T206 Wagner
      • Babe Ruth Cards
      • Sport Cards 1942-92
      • Topps Mantle
      • Modern Sport Cards
    • Baseball >
      • Baseball Bat
      • Baseball Jersey
      • Babe Ruth
      • Lou Gehrig
      • Mickey Mantle
    • Basketball >
      • Michael Jordan
      • Kobe Bryant
    • Ice Hockey
    • Sport 2nd page
  • Olympic Games
  • Origins of Sports
  • Historical Arms
    • Blade and Armour
    • Colt in Lifetime
    • Later Colts
    • Winchester
    • Firearms
  • Toys
  • Doll
  • Games
  • Stamps
    • US Stamps
    • Inverted Jenny
  • Inventions
  • Leica
  • Sciences
    • Ancient Science
    • Sciences 1600-1800
    • Astronomy
    • Physics
    • Medicine
  • Dinosaur
  • Computing
  • Nobel Medals
    • Nobel in Medicine
    • Nobel in Chemistry
  • Whisky
    • Whisky 2nd page
  • Wine
  • Plus
    • Plus 17C Art
    • Plus 18C Art
    • Plus 1910s
    • Plus 1982 Basquiat
    • Plus Ferrari
    • Plus US Cars
    • Plus Qing Porcelain
    • Plus Tribal
  • Work in Progress

Decade 1750-1759

Except otherwise stated, all results include the premium.
​See also : Canaletto  Chinese porcelain  Qing porcelain  Qianlong  Bird  Glass and crystal  Glass <1900  Jadeite
Decade 1740-1749

1736-1758 Brushpot in Enamel Glass
2008 SOLD for HK$ 73M by Christie's​​

In the 35th year of his reign matching 1696 CE, the Kangxi emperor devoted a place in the Imperial City to the enamel painting of glass vessels. This workshop was operated by Jesuits. The transparency of the glass offers the possibility of a supreme refinement but the yield is very low. The themes are often European.

The pieces produced without bubble and without crack which deserve to receive the imperial mark are almost nonexistent under Kangxi and Yongzheng. All of the items listed below have the Qianlong imperial mark. The know-how ceases to be maintained after 1758 CE.

Brushpots in enameled glass are extremely rare.

A 8.5 cm high piece with square section and canted corners was sold for HK $ 68M by Christie's in Hong Kong on November 27, 2007, lot 1665. Its buyer, the Taiwanese businessman Robert Tsao, put it back on sale in the same room on May 27, 2008 as a charity lot to help the victims of the Sichuan earthquake. It was sold for HK $ 73M, lot 1525.

A 6.1 cm high cylindrical falangcai enamel glass brush pot was sold for HK $ 49M by Christie's on November 28, 2012, 
lot 2124.

It is finely painted with an extended enamel palette on a translucent white glass reminiscent of the color of jade. Its slightly curved cylindrical shape is exquisite.

It features an elderly scholar inspecting a landscape hand scroll with the help of an assistant and of a young boy while the group on the other side is centered on an European in Chinese robe, possibly in reference to the role of the Jesuits in the development of the enamel painting on glass and porcelain.

An 18 cm high vase in the shape of an ovoid pouch was sold for HK $ 207M by Sotheby's on October 8, 2019. Snuff bottles are less rare. A rectangular piece 8 cm high was sold for HK $ 25.3M by Bonhams on November 28, 2011.
Glass and Crystal
Glass before 1900

1750 Han Cypress by the Qianlong Emperor
​2010 SOLD for RMB 87M by Poly

A poem by Du Fu is about the Wu emperor of the Han. In 110 BCE in quest of immortality, he visited the Songshan mountain, dubbed as The Father of Mountains, in current day Henan province. He viewed a millenarian tree with a lush foliage and said : "I have traveled all over the world, have never seen such a big cypress !" He named it a General.

The Han emperor went further and saw two even bigger cypresses, named Second General and Third General. 
A folk song narrates that the oldest and tallest "Third General" died in anger because he was dissatisfied with being ranked third.

In the 15th year of his reign matching 1750 CE, the Qianlong emperor walked in the steps of his Han predecessor, enjoying a cool breeze after the rain. The two surviving trees were still standing. He dedicated an autograph drawing to the bigger Second General, then 4,500 years old, 18.2 m high and 12.5 m in circumference, arguably the largest and oldest cypress in China.

The auspicious cypress has a strange appearance with mottled bark, a thick trunk, twisted branches, and protruding galls. The roots are rotten and hollow but young leaves are swaying on the branches, full of vitality. Through his precise but slightly trembling strokes, Qianlong expresses a wish for the longevity and health of his then 58 year old mother the empress dowager.

This imperial ink on paper 58 x 29 cm is probably fully autographwas sold for RMB 87M by Poly on December 4, 2010, lot 3643.

1751 Susana and the Elders by Batoni
2013 SOLD for $ 11.4M by Sotheby's

The Roman painter Pompeo Batoni is a follower of Guercino and a predecessor of David. His genre scenes are inspired by Baroque stories, but his painstaking drawing and color announce the classicism.

Famous as a portraitist, he had a long and prosperous career and took advantage of the wealthy English customers who visited Italy.

Susanna and the Elders is a large oil on canvas, 99 x 136 cm, made ​​in 1751 on order for a Viennese aristocrat. The action is violent and symbolizes the contrast of good and evil. The scene is beautifully situated in the grounds of a villa.

The young woman is at bath in a pool, but her textiles chastely cover her nakedness. Her bright and fresh skin is the strong point of the composition. The two assailants, one venal and the other despicable, are particularly unfriendly with their baroque old beards.

This painting was sold for $ 11.4M from a lower estimate of $ 6M by Sotheby's on January 31, 2013, lot 73.

1751 Yangcai Flower Vase
2014 SOLD for HK$ 57M by Sotheby's

The opening of the Kangxi emperor to the Western civilizations is the source of one of the best advances in Chinese ceramics, the falangcai, meaning foreign colors. The surface of the pottery is enameled over the glaze for offering a wide range of bright and saturated colors. 

At the end of the reign of Yongzheng followed by the beginning of Qianlong reign, while Tang Ying is the Superintendent for Jingdezhen, the artistic creation is at its best. Two variants of falangcai are used, the yingcai in a range of colors close to the wucai of the Ming, and the yangcai that incorporates the most recent invention of the pink enamel. 

On October 8, 2014, Sotheby's sold for HK $ 57M from a lower estimate of HK $ 30M a yangcai vase with floral decoration, lot 3639. 29 cm high in a nice slightly swollen pear shape, it is bearing the imperial Qianlong mark. 

The background of the decor is a deep lemon yellow, similar to a piece dated from the 7th year of the reign of Qianlong. Realistic flowers in a great botanical variety are the best excuse to offer an interesting range of colors. Their enamel has been deposited on a previously incised drawing, using a technique somewhat reminiscent of the cloisonne on metal. 

This piece is very rare both in its shape and its decorative theme. It is probably the survivor from a pair of vases delivered to the imperial collection in the 16th year of the reign of Qianlong, 1751 CE.

​1752 100 Birds Vase
2021 SOLD for RMB 266M by Poly

The manufacturing process of the reticulated revolving vase was arguably the most difficult ever, with the elements being assembled after separate firing. The Qianlong emperor wisely stopped it after pairing the last additional pieces to the production from the first batches.

The technology of the double vase nevertheless remained appealing for offering the most favorable auspices. Such pieces may be identified as turning heart bottles.

One of them, 63 cm high, is among the most massive in that category. The outer belly features a flying phoenix in a scenery. The open work matches the details of the landscape in irregular shapes, which is an additional feat with a higher risk of deformation during the firing. The rotation of the inner cylinder reveals the flock of ten species of auspicious birds in their flight facing the phoenix as a symbol of the harmonious balance of yin and yang.

The 
Divine Mother Empress Dowager Chongqing was held in very high regard by her son the Qianlong emperor and her 60th birthday in 1752 CE was one of the most lavish events of his reign.

The Imperial archives record that, on the fifth month of Qianlong's 18th year, the emperor commissioned Jingdezhen to fire a turning heart bottle with fighting dragons which was delivered by Tang Ying in the 11th month of the next year after 18 months of labor.

The yangcai vase with the phoenix was not documented. It was certainly prepared in the same period for a filial presenting to the empress dowager who was known to enjoy the story of the '100 birds'. It was sold for 
£ 330K by Christie's on June 15, 1999, lot 99, and for RMB 266M by Poly on June 7, 2021, lot 5153.

Asking Grok to c
ompare the Qianlong reticulated revolving vase sold by Poly on June 7, 2021, lot 5153 with the example whose sale at Bainbridges in 2010 has been cancelled. Compare their estimated dates of execution.
Overview
Both vases are exceptional examples of imperial Qing dynasty porcelain, specifically reticulated revolving (or rotating) types produced at the Jingdezhen kilns. These innovative designs, featuring an outer pierced (reticulated) shell that allows the inner rotating vase to be viewed through intricate openwork, were developed in the 1740s primarily to delight Emperor Qianlong (r. 1736–1795). They combine technical virtuosity—such as interlocking parts and multi-layered enameling—with auspicious symbolism, making them among the rarest and most prized Chinese ceramics. Only a handful of such vases survive in museum and private collections.
The Poly vase (lot 5153, sold June 7, 2021, at Poly International Auction Co., Beijing) fetched a world-record RMB 265.7 million (US$41.6 million), underscoring its status as a pinnacle of Qianlong craftsmanship. The Bainbridges example (offered November 11, 2010, at Bainbridges auction house, Ruislip, UK, as lot 800) achieved a hammer price of £43 million (approx. £53.1 million including premium), but the sale was cancelled due to the buyer's refusal to pay the auction house's 20% fee; it later sold privately for around £25 million in 2013.
While both share the Qianlong reign mark and period attribution, they differ in decoration, form, and specific provenance details.
​
Detailed description
Poly Vase (Lot 5153, 2021)
Description & Form
Four-piece construction: ruby-ground outer reticulated shell with carved openwork depicting phoenix scenes amid foliage and landscapes; inner baluster-form rotating vase with painted figural elements visible through the lattice; elegant tapering neck with archaistic kui dragon handles; overall height approx. 40–45 cm (estimated from images and comparables).
Decoration & Technique
Yangcai (foreign enamels) palette on ruby ground; intricate carved openwork (reticulation) for light transmission; revolving mechanism reveals inner scenes; combines reticulation, interlocking, and rotation—extremely rare fusion. Symbolism evokes imperial auspiciousness (phoenix for prosperity).
Provenance & History
Acquired by a veteran collector in 1999; exhibited in Poly's "Qianlong Palace Art" show prior to sale. No earlier imperial palace links documented publicly.
Auction Outcome
Sold successfully to an undisclosed buyer; set record for most expensive ceramic ever auctioned.
Rarity & Significance
One of only two known large-scale revolving phoenix examples (other in private Hong Kong collection); hailed as "world's most expensive ceramic" for its technical innovation.

Comparison of Estimated Dates of Execution
​
Both vases bear the six-character underglaze blue seal mark "Da Qing Qianlong Nian Zhi" (Made during the Qianlong reign of the Great Qing), confirming their attribution to the Qianlong period (1736–1795). Auction catalogs and expert analyses (e.g., from Sotheby's and Poly) describe them as definitively "Qianlong mark and period," with no doubts about authenticity raised. This places their execution squarely within the mid-to-late 18th century, during the height of Qianlong's patronage of porcelain innovation.
  • Specific Estimates:
    • Poly Vase: Dated broadly to the Qianlong period (1736–1795), with emphasis on the 1740s–1750s based on stylistic and technical comparables. Revolving vases were a novel invention around 1740 to satisfy the emperor's fascination with jade-like interlocking mechanisms in ceramics. The yangcai enameling and ruby ground align with peak production in the 1750s, when foreign enamel techniques were perfected at Jingdezhen.
    • Bainbridges Vase: Similarly dated to the Qianlong period (1736–1795), with catalog notes highlighting enameling styles from the mid-18th century (circa 1740s–1760s). The famille rose palette and reticulated motifs match documented imperial orders from the 1750s, though some experts note the gilt-heavy borders as slightly later within the reign (post-1750).
  • Similarities in Dating: No meaningful difference exists; both are estimated to the same reign (mid-18th century, ~1740–1760). This reflects the standardized imperial production under Qianlong, where such complex pieces were made in limited numbers for the palace. Variations in ground color (ruby vs. potentially yellow/blue for Bainbridges comparables) or motifs do not shift the timeline, as these were experimental within the same decade-spanning workshop.
  • Differences in Dating Precision: The Poly vase benefits from more recent scholarly scrutiny (e.g., Poly's 2021 exhibition), tying it explicitly to the 1740s innovation phase. The Bainbridges vase's 2010 catalog relies on traditional connoisseurship, with looser "Qianlong period" phrasing, but post-cancellation analyses (e.g., by Bonhams in 2013) reaffirm the mid-18th century without revision.
In summary, these vases exemplify Qianlong's era of porcelain opulence, with identical estimated execution dates underscoring their shared historical context. The Poly example edges out in technical complexity and market impact, while the Bainbridges vase endures as a cultural phenomenon due to its "lost sale" narrative. For further visuals or deeper provenance, museum comparables (e.g., National Palace Museum, Taipei) provide excellent parallels.
Chinese Porcelain
Qing Porcelain
Qianlong
Bird
18th Century

1752 Cinnabar Lacquer Box with Archer's Rings
2023 SOLD for HK$ 65M by Sotheby's

Since the Shang period the archers were using rings to protect the thumb from the string. This small piece was made of jade for the commanders and of hide for the troops. It was named 'she' in ancient China.

With time being, archery became less useful on the battlefield. The Qing dynasty, of Manchu origin, was fond of horse riding and revived the tradition of archery in their provincial armies known as the Eight Banners.

In the 17th year of his reign matching 1752 CE, the Qianlong emperor was presented with a jade ring which he praised in two poems as a reminder of the Manchu family law.

Around that time a cinnabar lacquer box and cover 12 cm in diameter was prepared to keep seven imperial rings. It is superbly carved in later Ming style with leaping carps, a homophony with joy and delight. These fish are swimming amidst cherry blossoms and crested waves. The base has the four character Qianlong mark.

The box was filled in compartments with archer's rings of identical form and size 3 cm in diameter and 2.2 cm high but in seven different colors of the jade : mutton fat white, translucent white with brown inclusions, mottled white and brown, translucent green jadeite with darker mottling, translucent spinach green with darker mottling, green-grey with brown skin and russet inclusions, white with a small russet patch. The rings have one rounded and one chamfered edge. A zitan liner was added in 1761.

All these elements were gradually inscribed with imperial appreciations. The poems inscribed on the rings date from 1757 to 1790. One of the white jades is also painted with a fishing scenery.

This set was sold by Sotheby's for HK $ 47M on April 8, 2007, lot 602 and for HK $ 65M on April 8, 2023, lot 15. Please watch the video shared in 2023 by the auction house.
Jadeite

1754 Bucintoro at the Molo
2005 SOLD for £ 11.4M by Christie's
2026 for sale on February 4 by Christie's

A view by Canaletto of the Bucintoro at the Molo, oil on canvas 152 x 138 cm painted ca 1754, was sold by Christie's for £ 11.4M on July 6, 2005, lot 20, and will be sold by the same auction house on February 4, 2026, lot 8.  The image is shared by Wikimedia.

This view is taken from the Riva degli Schiavoni, in the superb light of the end of the day, with the Bucentaur docked at the Molo. The 
waterfront paving is set at an exaggerated angle in the foreground.

Canaletto, settled in London since 1746, responded to a specific request from an English aristocratic family. The canvas is still in its period frame of English style, carved, pierced and gilded.

Compare with the ex Walpole 1732 view sold by Christie's on July 1, 2025, lot 8.

Overview
Canaletto (Giovanni Antonio Canal, 1697–1768) repeatedly depicted the annual Ascension Day festival in Venice, featuring the Bucintoro (the Doge's ceremonial galley) returning to the Molo (quayside near the Piazzetta and Doge's Palace) after the "Marriage to the Sea" ritual. The two paintings in question are variations on this iconic theme, painted over two decades apart, reflecting different periods in the artist's career.
The 1732 Version (ex-Walpole Collection)
  • Title: Venice, the Return of the Bucintoro on Ascension Day
  • Date: circa 1732 (early 1730s, Canaletto's peak Venetian period)
  • Dimensions: 33⅞ × 54⅜ in. (86 × 138.1 cm) — horizontal format
  • Provenance and Sales: Formerly owned by Britain's first Prime Minister, Sir Robert Walpole (hung at 10 Downing Street from 1736). Sold at Christie's London, 1 July 2025 (lot 8), for £31,935,000 — a record for the artist.
  • Style and Characteristics: Painted in Venice during Canaletto's "great decade." Features a wide, panoramic view across the Bacino di San Marco, with the lagoon foreground filled with gondolas and elegantly dressed figures. Warm early-summer light, confident brushwork (e.g., flicks for parasols and ribbons), meticulous detail, and vibrant atmosphere. Considered his earliest and most ambitious treatment of the subject, with supreme mastery and impeccable condition.
The ca. 1754 Version
  • Title: Venice, the Bucintoro at the Molo on Ascension Day
  • Date: circa 1754 (painted in England during Canaletto's residency there, 1746–1755)
  • Dimensions: Approximately 59¾ × 54 in. — nearly square, more vertical orientation
  • Provenance and Sales: Commissioned by the King family (later Earls of Lovelace). From the Champalimaud collection; sold at Christie's London, 6 July 2005 (lot 20), for around £11.4 million (then a record). Returning to auction at Christie's New York, 4 February 2026 (lot 8), estimate on request (around $30 million expected).
  • Style and Characteristics: Described as Canaletto's most spectacular and theatrical Venetian view from his English period. Monumental scale, daring composition, dazzling brushwork, and colorful palette. More focused and dramatic, with heightened pageantry and precision. Pristine preservation; considered one of his most visually powerful works, painted with supreme confidence late in his career.
Key Comparisons
  • Composition and Viewpoint — The 1732 version offers a broad, horizontal panorama emphasizing the bustling lagoon and distant Molo. The 1754 version is taller and more vertical, creating a theatrical, focused framing on the Bucintoro and architecture for greater drama.
  • Period and Technique — 1732: Peak freshness, warm tonality, and detailed staffage from his prime Venetian years. 1754: Mature confidence from England, with bolder colors, brushwork, and spectacle — described as "monumental" and "visually powerful."
  • Atmosphere and Light — Both capture festival energy, but the earlier is lighter and more atmospheric (early summer glow), while the later is more intense and theatrical.
  • Market Reception — The 1732 fetched a higher price (£31.9m in 2025), reflecting its earlier date and provenance. The 1754 set the prior record in 2005 and is poised for strong performance in 2026 due to rarity and condition.
Both are masterpieces of Canaletto's vedute, uniting topographical accuracy with festive vibrancy, but the 1732 represents his youthful brilliance, while the 1754 showcases his late, bold theatricality.
Canaletto - Venice, Bacino di San Marco on Ascension Day
Canaletto

1756-1759 Rat and Rabbit
2009 15.7 M€ including premium, UNPAID

Today, we are not just talking about auctions, but also on international politics. In September, just after the announcement of the sale of the Yves Saint-Laurent collection, Chinese lobbying groups have opposed the sale of two fountain ornaments. The echoes of the press show that these groups are increasingly active.

Twelve bronzes represented the Chinese zodiac in the main fountain at the palace of Qianlong in Beijing. They were the heads of the animals, and water flowed from their mouths at defined times. These figures are neither of Chinese or Western art, but a combination of the two: they were made on the plans of the Jesuit missionary Giuseppe Castiglione between 1756 and 1759.

This all disappeared at the looting of the palace by the Anglo-French troops in 1860, making today the opponents of the sale stating that the bronzes were stolen. Five statues were returned to China, five of them are not localized, and rat and rabbit are each estimated € 8 million in the sale of Christie's and Pierre Bergé in Paris from 23 to 25 February, 2009.

This price was announced, but curiously they are now the only lots in this three day sales catalog for which potential buyers must have the estimate confirmed by Christie's. I give you my personal opinion. Such pressure can intimidate a potential bidder. Christie's is perhaps in the process of seeking a buyer whose personality satisfies all parties. This is what Sotheby's did in 2007, when they removed the horse head from an announced sale. Stanley Ho bought it then privately for $ 69.1 MHK and donated it to the Chinese government.

The rat head is 30 cm high. The rabbit is higher ... through his ears!

POST SALE COMMENT

As prepared, rat and rabbit were presented separately. They were sold, both at the same price, € 15.7 million including premium.

The sale of these lots has not finished generating comments. I made two predictions, they have proved false. Buyers were not intimidated. Christie's and Pierre Bergé achieved the process without being intimidated, and therefore without recourse to a private transaction.

We must not forget that the activity that makes the difference between an international auction group and a national or local auction houses is their ability to convince buyers. The work done by Christie's to sell these two bronzes was probably huge.

These were the last two bronzes of the Imperial fountain to be available on the market. This has certainly increased their value.

In addition, the Chinese themselves, with their protests republished by the international press, have shown their interest in this group of works. Their price would certainly have been much lower if the dispute had not occurred.

It is something of a spectacular example which reinforces my premise: the price of an item at auction is a reliable metrics of the cultural importance given to this object at a dedicated time.

Now, five heads are lost. It should be very exciting if these excellent results push some of them to appear on the market.

2013 COMMENT

The travel back to China of rat and rabbit has just been decided.

The Chinese buyer of 2009 immediately said that he would not pay, and Mr. Bergé had kept the bronzes. They later entered into the ownership of Mr. Pinault who now presents them to China. Christie's facilitated this operation.

Both bronzes are shown in the story shared by Bloomberg.

1757 Su Shi's Boating Pavilion by Qian Weicheng
2019 SOLD for RMB 75M by China Guardian

The Qianlong emperor was a keen admirer of Su Shi. In 1757 CE, during his second southern tour, he visited Su Shi's Mooring Boat (Yizhou) Pavilion in Changzhou, the city where the famous poet, calligrapher, painter and politician of Song period had died in exile in 1101 CE.

The brilliant mandarin and scholar Qian Weicheng, a native of Changzhou, took this opportunity to paint a scenery with the pavilion. The Qianlong emperor was so delighted that he wrote a poem on the spot and another one 27 years later when he passed through Changzhou on his sixth southern tour, 12 years after the death of the artist.

This thick and light ink and color on paper 26 x 75 cm was sold for RMB 75M from a lower estimate of RMB 50M by China Guardian on November 19, 2019, lot 1369. The handscroll includes the title and two postscripts.

There are as many as 165 paintings by Qian Weicheng in Qianlong's collection catalog Shiqu Baoji.

1758 Dresden by Bellotto
2020 SOLD for £ 5.4M by Sotheby's

A pupil and nephew of Canaletto, Bernardo Bellotto left Venice in 1747. Until his death in 1780, he settled successively in the main capitals of Northern Europe, where he exported the Vedutist style with great success. Far from his uncle who left for London in 1746, Bernardo did not hesitate to call himself "Canaletto".

The first stopover is Dresden, where from 1748 he occupies the position of court painter. Bellotto paints topographical views with the same thoroughness as his uncle and in cold colors. The almost identical variants can often be dated by the state of the monuments. Fourteen large format views are being prepared for the Royal Gallery. One of them, 132 x 247 cm, shows the alignment of monuments along the Elbe. A 96 x 165 cm autograph copy passed at Christie's on July 9, 2015.

From 1961 to 2005, a view of the galleries of the Zwinger, the pleasure palace of the Elector of Saxony, adorned the presidential residence in Bonn. It had been forcibly acquired in 1938 for the use of the Führermuseum and has now been returned to the heirs of the looted collector. This oil on canvas 48 x 80 cm was sold for £ 5.4M from a lower estimate of  £ 3M by Sotheby's on July 28, 2020, lot 33. The image is shared by Wikimedia.

The Zwinger had been built on ancient fortifications outside the city. The painting shows a side view behind a canal animated by swans. A rudimentary wooden bridge leads to an orangery with a promenade.

The original was an oil on canvas 133 x 235 cm. Its variant can be dated to 1758, the year Bellotto left for Vienna. It is very comparable by its overall composition and by almost all the details to an etching 53 x 84 cm printed in that year with a title in French by "Ber(d) Bellotto dit Canaletto".
Bernardo Bellotto - Dresden, A view of the moat of the Zwinger, Sotheby's auction July 2020

​1759-1760 The Blue Goats by Lang Shining
2025 SOLD for HK$ 59M by Sotheby's

Giuseppe Castiglione arrived in Beijing in the 54th year of Kangxi, 1715 CE. The skills of this young man aged 27 appealed to the emperor and he became a court painter under the name Lang Shining. He never left the imperial court. In his outstanding career that lasted half a century without harm or conflict, he assimilated the traditional techniques of Chinese graphic art without forgetting his original training.

The court painters were considered as imperial officials and did not sign their works. Lang Shining and his studio are credited with near certainty for the paintings that incorporate such Western features like perspective or like the shades that enhance the realism of the face.

From 1757 CE the Qianlong emperor was facing a revolt on the northwestern border. Two years later the rebel army was crushed in the mountains of current-day Afghanistan. Desiring to highlight the civilizing force of the Qing, the emperor commissioned in November a painting featuring two 'blue' goats. This sharp hoof chamois famous for its untamed agility in climbing cliffs is symbolizing the feat of the Chinese army in defeating the rebels whose surrender and resilience prevent further leaps.

The completed work entrusted by Lang Shining was presented to the emperor along with two other paintings by the same artist on the 3rd day of the 6th lunar month of the 25th year of Qianlong matching 1760 CE. The animals are painted in a European realistic style with beautiful details including the texture of the fur. The landscape is likely by a Chinese hand. Indeed the emperor did not like the Western landscape style.

​The Blue Goats, ink and color hanging scroll on silk 220 x 190 m, is signed by Jin Tingbiao, a collaborator to Lang Shining, and inscribed on imperial order by a scribe with the Qianlong poem that inspired it. It was sold for HK $ 59M by Sotheby's on May 7, 2025, lot 9501. Please watch the video shared by the auction house.

The autograph master copy 243 x 214 cm signed by Lang Shining is kept at the National Palace Museum at Taipei. The landscape is different.
Decade 1760-1769
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.