China
Except otherwise stated, all results include the premium.
See also : Song Yuan Ming Qianlong Modern China Buddhism Chinese calligraphy Chinese art Mountains in China Textiles Chinese porcelain Qing porcelain Abstract art II Qi Baishi Zao Wou-Ki Chinese dragon Animals Bird Landscape Cities
Chronology : 1000-1400 15th century 1400-1429 17th century 1610-1619 18th century 1740-1749 1760-1769 20th century 1920-1929 1925 1940-1949 1946 1955 1980-1989 1985
See also : Song Yuan Ming Qianlong Modern China Buddhism Chinese calligraphy Chinese art Mountains in China Textiles Chinese porcelain Qing porcelain Abstract art II Qi Baishi Zao Wou-Ki Chinese dragon Animals Bird Landscape Cities
Chronology : 1000-1400 15th century 1400-1429 17th century 1610-1619 18th century 1740-1749 1760-1769 20th century 1920-1929 1925 1940-1949 1946 1955 1980-1989 1985
1083-1085 Wood and Rock by Su Shi
2018 SOLD for HK$ 460M by Christie's
Under the Song, the literati are philosophers and humanists who sometimes have the audacity to oppose imperial politics. Their supreme mode of expression is calligraphy, which conveys to their readers the firmness and rhythm of their thought.
In 1071 CE, Su Shi had been expelled from the capital, starting at the age of 34 a second career as a provincial servant with increasingly mediocre missions despite his immense talent. He died in 1101. His younger friend Mi Fu escaped political persecution by his reputation for eccentricity. They were the two best calligraphers in their lifetime.
A nine-character autograph message on a 28 x 9.5 cm sheet sent by Su Shi to the governor of a locality that he was leaving was sold for $ 8.2M by Sotheby's on September 19, 2013.
Graphic art is exceptional in their works. The movement of the artist's hand is the same as for calligraphy. The rare drawings by Su Shi translate emotions too deep to be expressed in words. Mi Fu will only paint in the last years of his life, mostly after Su Shi's death.
On November 26, 2018, Christie's sold for HK $ 460M as lot 8008 a 26 x 50 cm ink on paper painted by Su Shi. This piece is extended by many colophons including an appreciation calligraphed by Mi Fu, and includes many seals. Please watch two videos shared by the auction house.
The image consists of two elements that join together : a leafless tree twisted into several undulations and a bulky rock. The dryness of the tree expresses the desolation of the artist in his exile while at the opposite edge on the left flank of the rock the sparse bamboos bring the hope of a new vitality.
Grokipedia input :
A rare purported authentic piece, Wood and Rock (also known as Frightened Wood and Strange Rock), depicts a gnarled tree and craggy rock in ink monochrome, symbolizing endurance amid adversity; this handscroll, dated to the 11th century, surfaced in auctions and is prized for its expressive minimalism, though debates persist on its genuineness due to the era's copying practices.
Grok reply to Grokipedia :
The description provided about Su Shi's "Wood and Rock" (also known as "Withered Tree and Strange Rock" in some translations) largely aligns with historical and art scholarship on the piece. This 11th-century handscroll, attributed to the Song dynasty polymath Su Shi (1037–1101), features a minimalist ink-on-paper depiction of a gnarled, leafless tree alongside a craggy rock, with emerging bamboo shoots adding subtle vitality. The composition, measuring approximately 26.3 x 50 cm for the painting itself (expanding to over 5 meters with colophons and mounting), embodies themes of resilience and harmony between nature and human experience, often interpreted as symbolizing endurance through life's adversities and the passage of time.
Su Shi, a renowned poet, calligrapher, statesman, and artist—often likened to a "Renaissance man" predating Leonardo da Vinci—pioneered a spontaneous, expressive style in literati painting that departed from the meticulous academic traditions of his era. This work exemplifies that innovation through its bold, impressionistic brushstrokes and minimalism, prioritizing personal expression over detailed realism. It includes colophons (inscriptions) by contemporaries like Liu Liangzuo (11th century) and the celebrated calligrapher Mi Fu (1051–1107), as well as later additions up to the 16th century, along with 41 collector's seals that trace its provenance.
The handscroll was originally a gift from Su Shi to a friend in Runzhou (modern Zhenjiang) and remained in private collections for centuries, including Japanese ownership from 1937 onward. It gained international attention when it surfaced at Christie's Hong Kong auction in November 2018, selling for HK$463.6 million (about US$59.2 million)—one of the highest prices for a classical Chinese painting at the time, though it fell short of breaking the overall Asian art record. As of mid-2025, it ranks among the top five most expensive Chinese scroll paintings ever auctioned.
Debates on its authenticity stem from the Song dynasty's prevalent copying practices, the scarcity of surviving Su Shi works (only one or two confirmed paintings exist, with another, "Bamboo and Rock," held by the National Art Museum of China), and its limited public exposure prior to the 2018 sale. Some scholars have questioned attribution based on stylistic analysis and historical documentation, with lingering skepticism noted around its undocumented periods in imperial collections. However, Christie's specialists and art historians, citing the colophons, seals, and brushwork consistency with Su Shi's known style, affirm its genuineness, emphasizing its role in illustrating the evolution of Chinese ink painting. The piece's cultural significance endures, reflecting Su Shi's profound influence on subsequent generations of artists.
In 1071 CE, Su Shi had been expelled from the capital, starting at the age of 34 a second career as a provincial servant with increasingly mediocre missions despite his immense talent. He died in 1101. His younger friend Mi Fu escaped political persecution by his reputation for eccentricity. They were the two best calligraphers in their lifetime.
A nine-character autograph message on a 28 x 9.5 cm sheet sent by Su Shi to the governor of a locality that he was leaving was sold for $ 8.2M by Sotheby's on September 19, 2013.
Graphic art is exceptional in their works. The movement of the artist's hand is the same as for calligraphy. The rare drawings by Su Shi translate emotions too deep to be expressed in words. Mi Fu will only paint in the last years of his life, mostly after Su Shi's death.
On November 26, 2018, Christie's sold for HK $ 460M as lot 8008 a 26 x 50 cm ink on paper painted by Su Shi. This piece is extended by many colophons including an appreciation calligraphed by Mi Fu, and includes many seals. Please watch two videos shared by the auction house.
The image consists of two elements that join together : a leafless tree twisted into several undulations and a bulky rock. The dryness of the tree expresses the desolation of the artist in his exile while at the opposite edge on the left flank of the rock the sparse bamboos bring the hope of a new vitality.
Grokipedia input :
A rare purported authentic piece, Wood and Rock (also known as Frightened Wood and Strange Rock), depicts a gnarled tree and craggy rock in ink monochrome, symbolizing endurance amid adversity; this handscroll, dated to the 11th century, surfaced in auctions and is prized for its expressive minimalism, though debates persist on its genuineness due to the era's copying practices.
Grok reply to Grokipedia :
The description provided about Su Shi's "Wood and Rock" (also known as "Withered Tree and Strange Rock" in some translations) largely aligns with historical and art scholarship on the piece. This 11th-century handscroll, attributed to the Song dynasty polymath Su Shi (1037–1101), features a minimalist ink-on-paper depiction of a gnarled, leafless tree alongside a craggy rock, with emerging bamboo shoots adding subtle vitality. The composition, measuring approximately 26.3 x 50 cm for the painting itself (expanding to over 5 meters with colophons and mounting), embodies themes of resilience and harmony between nature and human experience, often interpreted as symbolizing endurance through life's adversities and the passage of time.
Su Shi, a renowned poet, calligrapher, statesman, and artist—often likened to a "Renaissance man" predating Leonardo da Vinci—pioneered a spontaneous, expressive style in literati painting that departed from the meticulous academic traditions of his era. This work exemplifies that innovation through its bold, impressionistic brushstrokes and minimalism, prioritizing personal expression over detailed realism. It includes colophons (inscriptions) by contemporaries like Liu Liangzuo (11th century) and the celebrated calligrapher Mi Fu (1051–1107), as well as later additions up to the 16th century, along with 41 collector's seals that trace its provenance.
The handscroll was originally a gift from Su Shi to a friend in Runzhou (modern Zhenjiang) and remained in private collections for centuries, including Japanese ownership from 1937 onward. It gained international attention when it surfaced at Christie's Hong Kong auction in November 2018, selling for HK$463.6 million (about US$59.2 million)—one of the highest prices for a classical Chinese painting at the time, though it fell short of breaking the overall Asian art record. As of mid-2025, it ranks among the top five most expensive Chinese scroll paintings ever auctioned.
Debates on its authenticity stem from the Song dynasty's prevalent copying practices, the scarcity of surviving Su Shi works (only one or two confirmed paintings exist, with another, "Bamboo and Rock," held by the National Art Museum of China), and its limited public exposure prior to the 2018 sale. Some scholars have questioned attribution based on stylistic analysis and historical documentation, with lingering skepticism noted around its undocumented periods in imperial collections. However, Christie's specialists and art historians, citing the colophons, seals, and brushwork consistency with Su Shi's known style, affirm its genuineness, emphasizing its role in illustrating the evolution of Chinese ink painting. The piece's cultural significance endures, reflecting Su Shi's profound influence on subsequent generations of artists.
Relationship Between Su Shi and Mi Fu
Su Shi (1037–1101, also known as Su Dongpo) and Mi Fu (1051–1107, also known as Mi Youren or Haiyue Jushi) were prominent figures of the Northern Song dynasty (960–1127), both renowned as scholar-officials, poets, calligraphers, and painters. They shared a deep personal friendship and intellectual bond, forged during their overlapping careers in government service and artistic circles in cities like Kaifeng and Yangzhou. This relationship is well-documented in historical records, such as Su Shi's letters and Mi Fu's writings, where they exchanged poems, critiqued each other's works, and collaborated on artistic projects. Mi Fu, in particular, admired Su Shi's innovative approach to painting, which emphasized expressive brushwork over realistic depiction—a style Mi Fu himself emulated and championed. Their friendship exemplifies the literati (wenren) ideal of the Song era, where art, poetry, and philosophy intertwined among elites. In the context of Wood and Rock, Mi Fu's colophon (appreciation) not only praises Su Shi's painting but also responds poetically to a rhyme initiated by another mutual acquaintance, Liu Liangzuo, underscoring their collaborative creative exchanges. Christie's catalog describes Mi Fu explicitly as "a close friend of Su Shi," highlighting how his inscription elevates the scroll as a testament to their shared legacy in advancing ink painting and calligraphy as vehicles for personal expression.
Estimated Date of the Painting and Colophon
The painting Wood and Rock by Su Shi depicts a gnarled, withered tree emerging from a fantastical, cloud-like rock formation, executed in bold, expressive ink washes on paper—a hallmark of Su Shi's late style symbolizing resilience amid adversity (reflecting his own political exiles). Based on the colophons and historical provenance detailed in the Christie's auction catalog:
Su Shi (1037–1101, also known as Su Dongpo) and Mi Fu (1051–1107, also known as Mi Youren or Haiyue Jushi) were prominent figures of the Northern Song dynasty (960–1127), both renowned as scholar-officials, poets, calligraphers, and painters. They shared a deep personal friendship and intellectual bond, forged during their overlapping careers in government service and artistic circles in cities like Kaifeng and Yangzhou. This relationship is well-documented in historical records, such as Su Shi's letters and Mi Fu's writings, where they exchanged poems, critiqued each other's works, and collaborated on artistic projects. Mi Fu, in particular, admired Su Shi's innovative approach to painting, which emphasized expressive brushwork over realistic depiction—a style Mi Fu himself emulated and championed. Their friendship exemplifies the literati (wenren) ideal of the Song era, where art, poetry, and philosophy intertwined among elites. In the context of Wood and Rock, Mi Fu's colophon (appreciation) not only praises Su Shi's painting but also responds poetically to a rhyme initiated by another mutual acquaintance, Liu Liangzuo, underscoring their collaborative creative exchanges. Christie's catalog describes Mi Fu explicitly as "a close friend of Su Shi," highlighting how his inscription elevates the scroll as a testament to their shared legacy in advancing ink painting and calligraphy as vehicles for personal expression.
Estimated Date of the Painting and Colophon
The painting Wood and Rock by Su Shi depicts a gnarled, withered tree emerging from a fantastical, cloud-like rock formation, executed in bold, expressive ink washes on paper—a hallmark of Su Shi's late style symbolizing resilience amid adversity (reflecting his own political exiles). Based on the colophons and historical provenance detailed in the Christie's auction catalog:
- Date of the Painting: Estimated to 1083–1085 CE. This is inferred from the colophon by Liu Liangzuo (11th century, active ca. 1070s–1090s), a contemporary mutual friend of Su Shi and Mi Fu. Liu describes the recipient, "Master Feng" (a Taoist scholar in Runzhou/Zhenjiang), as being in his seventies with "dark beard and hair ever glowing," indicating advanced age and a long acquaintance. Liu notes it has been "thirty years" since Master Feng resigned his post to pursue Taoism, placing the gift and painting around the early 1080s. Su Shi was exiled to Huangzhou (Hubei) from 1080–1084, a period of intense creative output, aligning with the work's stylistic maturity and thematic depth.
- Date of Mi Fu's Colophon (Appreciation): Estimated to 1085–1087 CE. Mi Fu's inscription directly follows Liu Liangzuo's in the handscroll, responding to the same poetic rhyme with his own verses (beginning "Fu, following the rhyme: Who can say what it is like at the age of forty?"). This suggests it was added shortly after Liu's, during a brief window when the scroll circulated among their circle in the mid-1080s. Mi Fu was then in his mid-30s, serving as an official in Yangzhou (near Runzhou), making such an exchange feasible. Later colophons (e.g., by Yu Xilu in 1333 and Guo Chang in 1614) reference Mi Fu's addition as contemporaneous with the painting, reinforcing this timeline.
Christie’s Announces 1000-year-old $50m Su Shi Scroll https://t.co/eVdovdYFyr pic.twitter.com/XpeTTOdBby
— Art Market Monitor (@artmarket) August 30, 2018
1095 Di Zhu Ming by Huang Tinjian
2010 SOLD for RMB 436M by Poly
A scroll of paper from Song period was sold for RMB 436M by Poly on June 3, 2010. It is completely covered with characters drawn in ink by Huang Tingjian, one of the most famous master calligraphers of his time. It is a fine example of his art consisting of semi-cursive letters in an energetic and accentuated style. Depending on location, this text includes from 4 to 15 characters within the height.
Completed around 1095 CE, this scroll is 37 cm high with a length exceeding 8 m, 15 m including the colohons contains 600 characters of which some examples are presented in the article shared by China Daily. Titled Di Zhu Ming, it is a copy of a Tang poem. It includes a small portrait of the calligrapher artist.
Significance as a Complete Copy of a Tang Poem
Huang Tingjian's Dizhuming handscroll, created around 1095 during the Northern Song dynasty, transcribes a complete Tang dynasty poem titled Di Zhu Ming (likely referring to a work evoking themes of "emperor's bamboo inscription" or similar, though exact attribution varies in sources; it draws from Tang poetic traditions emphasizing nature, impermanence, and scholarly reflection). This is not a mere excerpt but a full, verbatim reproduction spanning approximately 600 characters, preserving the original Tang text's structure, rhythm, and imagery in semi-cursive (running) script. Its cultural weight lies in bridging Tang and Song literary worlds: the Tang era (618–907) represented the pinnacle of classical Chinese poetry, with masters like Li Bai and Du Fu setting enduring standards. By faithfully copying and thus revitalizing a Tang poem, Huang elevated it as a scholarly act of homage and transmission, aligning with Song literati's obsession with antiquity amid political turmoil (Huang himself faced exile in 1095 for his reformist associations). This "complete copy" underscores themes of cultural continuity—echoing Tang motifs of exile and resilience—while subtly critiquing Song court politics through the poem's undertones of loss and endurance. In the broader Song context, such transcriptions fueled the Jiangxi School of Poetry, which Huang founded, emphasizing "allusion and transformation" (bianfa) of Tang sources to innovate without rupture. The scroll's 2010 Poly Auction sale for RMB 436.5 million ($64 million USD) highlighted its role in modern cultural repatriation, symbolizing China's reclamation of Tang-Song heritage from Japanese collections.
Significance in Its Own Right as a Song Handscroll of Calligraphy
Beyond its role as a conduit for Tang poetry, Dizhuming stands as an autonomous masterpiece of Song calligraphy, exemplifying Huang's innovative "wild cursive" style influenced by Tang monk Huaisu (737–799) and his mentor Su Shi. Measuring about 8–10 meters in length (with colophons extending it to 15 meters), the handscroll format—unrolled sequentially for intimate viewing—embodies Song literati ideals of spontaneity (ziran) and self-expression, where calligraphy becomes "a picture of the mind" (xintu). Huang's script features bold, wave-like strokes, rhythmic ink density variations (dry to moist), and energetic flourishes that convey moral vigor and emotional depth, diverging from Tang's formal regularity toward Song's introspective dynamism. As one of the "Four Masters of Song Calligraphy" (with Su Shi, Mi Fu, and Cai Xiang), Huang's work here marks a stylistic evolution in his later years: more fluid and "transformed" than his earlier pieces, reflecting his exile's philosophical turn toward Chan Buddhist detachment. Its 600 characters pulse with vitality, turning transcription into creation—each stroke a meditation on impermanence, mirroring the poem's themes. This handscroll influenced subsequent generations, inspiring Ming-Qing collectors and modern auctions, where it set records not just for price but for embodying Song's shift from imperial grandeur to personal artistry. In essence, Dizhuming is a performative artifact: a scroll that, when unrolled, unfolds Huang's inner world, making it a cornerstone of Chinese calligraphy's expressive tradition.
Condition and Authentication of the Handscroll
The Dizhuming scroll is in remarkably well-preserved condition for a 900-year-old artifact, with minimal fading, tears, or insect damage, thanks to its provenance in protected Japanese and Taiwanese collections post-Song era. The core calligraphy remains vibrant, with original ink tones intact and paper supple, though age-related discoloration appears in mounting silk. Colophons—over 20 inscriptions from Song to Qing connoisseurs, including a Song emperor's seal—add historical layers but introduce minor repairs (e.g., silk reinforcements in the 18th century). Post-2010 auction conservation by Poly International likely involved pH-neutral mounting to stabilize it further.
Authentication has been rigorous and layered. Initially doubted during the Qing Qianlong era (1735–1796) as a "counterfeit" due to its atypical style (bolder than Huang's standard works), it was reaffirmed in the 20th century by Taiwanese scholar and calligrapher Tuo Zhonghua, who identified stylistic hallmarks like Huang's signature "rippling" horizontals and pressure variations, dating it precisely to 1095 via historical records of Huang's exile. Provenance traces to Song imperial collections, then Japanese temples (e.g., a private Kyoto museum until the 1980s), and a Taiwanese collector before the 2010 sale. Poly Auction's pre-sale experts, including infrared analysis and comparative studies against authenticated Huang works (e.g., Poem on the Hall of Pines and Wind at the National Palace Museum, Taipei), confirmed genuineness. No major disputes persist today; it's hailed as Huang's longest surviving regular-script scroll, with its $64 million price reflecting unassailable scholarly consensus.
Completed around 1095 CE, this scroll is 37 cm high with a length exceeding 8 m, 15 m including the colohons contains 600 characters of which some examples are presented in the article shared by China Daily. Titled Di Zhu Ming, it is a copy of a Tang poem. It includes a small portrait of the calligrapher artist.
Significance as a Complete Copy of a Tang Poem
Huang Tingjian's Dizhuming handscroll, created around 1095 during the Northern Song dynasty, transcribes a complete Tang dynasty poem titled Di Zhu Ming (likely referring to a work evoking themes of "emperor's bamboo inscription" or similar, though exact attribution varies in sources; it draws from Tang poetic traditions emphasizing nature, impermanence, and scholarly reflection). This is not a mere excerpt but a full, verbatim reproduction spanning approximately 600 characters, preserving the original Tang text's structure, rhythm, and imagery in semi-cursive (running) script. Its cultural weight lies in bridging Tang and Song literary worlds: the Tang era (618–907) represented the pinnacle of classical Chinese poetry, with masters like Li Bai and Du Fu setting enduring standards. By faithfully copying and thus revitalizing a Tang poem, Huang elevated it as a scholarly act of homage and transmission, aligning with Song literati's obsession with antiquity amid political turmoil (Huang himself faced exile in 1095 for his reformist associations). This "complete copy" underscores themes of cultural continuity—echoing Tang motifs of exile and resilience—while subtly critiquing Song court politics through the poem's undertones of loss and endurance. In the broader Song context, such transcriptions fueled the Jiangxi School of Poetry, which Huang founded, emphasizing "allusion and transformation" (bianfa) of Tang sources to innovate without rupture. The scroll's 2010 Poly Auction sale for RMB 436.5 million ($64 million USD) highlighted its role in modern cultural repatriation, symbolizing China's reclamation of Tang-Song heritage from Japanese collections.
Significance in Its Own Right as a Song Handscroll of Calligraphy
Beyond its role as a conduit for Tang poetry, Dizhuming stands as an autonomous masterpiece of Song calligraphy, exemplifying Huang's innovative "wild cursive" style influenced by Tang monk Huaisu (737–799) and his mentor Su Shi. Measuring about 8–10 meters in length (with colophons extending it to 15 meters), the handscroll format—unrolled sequentially for intimate viewing—embodies Song literati ideals of spontaneity (ziran) and self-expression, where calligraphy becomes "a picture of the mind" (xintu). Huang's script features bold, wave-like strokes, rhythmic ink density variations (dry to moist), and energetic flourishes that convey moral vigor and emotional depth, diverging from Tang's formal regularity toward Song's introspective dynamism. As one of the "Four Masters of Song Calligraphy" (with Su Shi, Mi Fu, and Cai Xiang), Huang's work here marks a stylistic evolution in his later years: more fluid and "transformed" than his earlier pieces, reflecting his exile's philosophical turn toward Chan Buddhist detachment. Its 600 characters pulse with vitality, turning transcription into creation—each stroke a meditation on impermanence, mirroring the poem's themes. This handscroll influenced subsequent generations, inspiring Ming-Qing collectors and modern auctions, where it set records not just for price but for embodying Song's shift from imperial grandeur to personal artistry. In essence, Dizhuming is a performative artifact: a scroll that, when unrolled, unfolds Huang's inner world, making it a cornerstone of Chinese calligraphy's expressive tradition.
Condition and Authentication of the Handscroll
The Dizhuming scroll is in remarkably well-preserved condition for a 900-year-old artifact, with minimal fading, tears, or insect damage, thanks to its provenance in protected Japanese and Taiwanese collections post-Song era. The core calligraphy remains vibrant, with original ink tones intact and paper supple, though age-related discoloration appears in mounting silk. Colophons—over 20 inscriptions from Song to Qing connoisseurs, including a Song emperor's seal—add historical layers but introduce minor repairs (e.g., silk reinforcements in the 18th century). Post-2010 auction conservation by Poly International likely involved pH-neutral mounting to stabilize it further.
Authentication has been rigorous and layered. Initially doubted during the Qing Qianlong era (1735–1796) as a "counterfeit" due to its atypical style (bolder than Huang's standard works), it was reaffirmed in the 20th century by Taiwanese scholar and calligrapher Tuo Zhonghua, who identified stylistic hallmarks like Huang's signature "rippling" horizontals and pressure variations, dating it precisely to 1095 via historical records of Huang's exile. Provenance traces to Song imperial collections, then Japanese temples (e.g., a private Kyoto museum until the 1980s), and a Taiwanese collector before the 2010 sale. Poly Auction's pre-sale experts, including infrared analysis and comparative studies against authenticated Huang works (e.g., Poem on the Hall of Pines and Wind at the National Palace Museum, Taipei), confirmed genuineness. No major disputes persist today; it's hailed as Huang's longest surviving regular-script scroll, with its $64 million price reflecting unassailable scholarly consensus.
1244 Six Dragons attributed to Chen Rong
2017 SOLD for $ 49M by Christie's
The dragons, symbols of the emperor and his family, know how to confront the forces of nature. Their sinuous bodies sail like in weightlessness amidst clouds and waves. The varied expressions of their faces are always vigorous.
The hand scroll is an art much more refined than a mere drawing. The image is read from right to left as it is unfolded, offering the scene of a real action. The paper should also be exquisite in the touch.
Towards the end of the Southern Song Dynasty, the artist Chen Rong pushed his ink pictures of dragons to the rank of masterpieces. His scrolls were much admired by the Qianlong emperor who commented on the colophons and stamped his seals.
The drawing of the fabulous beast by Chen Rong is sharp and detailed, in contrast to its wet surrounding realized by an original method of ink spraying. In the Taoist tradition, such a scene is a magical summon to rain.
The Boston Museum retains a scroll starring nine young sons of the Dragon King, 46 cm high for 15 m long, including on the painting two autograph inscriptions that provide an estimate of the date of the artwork at 1244 of our calendar.
A scroll featuring six dragons in a style similar as in the Boston specimen was sold for $ 49M from a lower estimate of $ 1.2M by Christie's on March 15, 2017 after deaccession from the Fujita Museum in Osaka, lot 507. Signed by one seal of the artist, it is 35 cm high with a length of 4.40 m for the image and 83 cm for the calligraphy. It is handled for our pleasure in the video shared by the auction house.
Grok thought :
Quote
Christie's @ChristiesInc Mar 16, 2017
Six Dragons handscroll attributed to Chen Rong, from the Fujita Museum sold for $48,967,500 against high estimate of $1.8m #AsianArtWeek
The Northern Song (960–1127) saw dragons integrated into ritual and philosophical contexts, such as the four ling (spiritual creatures) including the azure dragon representing spring and renewal, often tied to Confucian ideals of sage rulers. However, the Southern Song (1127–1279) marked a pivotal shift, where amid national hardships from invasions and political instability, artists used dragons to express collective emotions, spiritual aspirations, and resilience, portraying them as dynamic symbols of the Chinese nation's sovereignty rather than mere imperial emblems. Over time, depictions transitioned from wild, serpentine forms to more domesticated, almost pet-like figures with rounded features, mirroring the urbanization and humanization of society.
A key artist elevating this theme was Chen Rong (c. 1200–1266), a Southern Song scholar-official renowned for his "ink dragons," which captured the creatures' ethereal power through bold brushwork, splattered ink for mist and clouds, and dramatic compositions evoking movement and symbiosis with nature. His works, such as the 1244 handscroll Nine Dragons, show nine dragons twisting through waves, rocks, and clouds, symbolizing prosperity and the cyclical forces of the universe—often used in rain-summoning rituals to invoke agricultural abundance.
Other examples include Five Dragons, where violent dragons stir waterfalls amid rainclouds, emphasizing their role in ecological balance, and Eleven Dragons, a handscroll highlighting their majestic, cloud-breathing forms.
Dragons also appeared alongside tigers in yin-yang pairings, as in Fachang Muqi's Dragon; Tiger, representing complementary opposites in a misty, contemplative style. Beyond painting, the motif adorned ceramics, lacquerware, and bronzes, reinforcing prosperity and protection in everyday and imperial contexts. This enduring theme influenced later dynasties, blending mysticism with cultural identity.
The hand scroll is an art much more refined than a mere drawing. The image is read from right to left as it is unfolded, offering the scene of a real action. The paper should also be exquisite in the touch.
Towards the end of the Southern Song Dynasty, the artist Chen Rong pushed his ink pictures of dragons to the rank of masterpieces. His scrolls were much admired by the Qianlong emperor who commented on the colophons and stamped his seals.
The drawing of the fabulous beast by Chen Rong is sharp and detailed, in contrast to its wet surrounding realized by an original method of ink spraying. In the Taoist tradition, such a scene is a magical summon to rain.
The Boston Museum retains a scroll starring nine young sons of the Dragon King, 46 cm high for 15 m long, including on the painting two autograph inscriptions that provide an estimate of the date of the artwork at 1244 of our calendar.
A scroll featuring six dragons in a style similar as in the Boston specimen was sold for $ 49M from a lower estimate of $ 1.2M by Christie's on March 15, 2017 after deaccession from the Fujita Museum in Osaka, lot 507. Signed by one seal of the artist, it is 35 cm high with a length of 4.40 m for the image and 83 cm for the calligraphy. It is handled for our pleasure in the video shared by the auction house.
Grok thought :
Quote
Christie's @ChristiesInc Mar 16, 2017
Six Dragons handscroll attributed to Chen Rong, from the Fujita Museum sold for $48,967,500 against high estimate of $1.8m #AsianArtWeek
- This 2017 Christie's post celebrates the surprise sale of a 13th-century Song Dynasty handscroll "Six Dragons" by Chen Rong, which soared to $48.97 million—exceeding its $1.8 million high estimate by over 27 times—amid fierce bidding during Asia Week New York.
- The ink-on-paper scroll, depicting six ethereal dragons swirling through misty clouds, originates from Japan's Fujita Museum collection and was catalogued in the Qing Dynasty's imperial Shiqu Baoji archive, underscoring its rare historical provenance.
- The auction's outcome reflected surging global interest in classical Chinese art, funding Fujita Museum renovations while setting a then-record for a Chinese painting, as conservative estimates masked the work's authenticated imperial allure.
The Northern Song (960–1127) saw dragons integrated into ritual and philosophical contexts, such as the four ling (spiritual creatures) including the azure dragon representing spring and renewal, often tied to Confucian ideals of sage rulers. However, the Southern Song (1127–1279) marked a pivotal shift, where amid national hardships from invasions and political instability, artists used dragons to express collective emotions, spiritual aspirations, and resilience, portraying them as dynamic symbols of the Chinese nation's sovereignty rather than mere imperial emblems. Over time, depictions transitioned from wild, serpentine forms to more domesticated, almost pet-like figures with rounded features, mirroring the urbanization and humanization of society.
A key artist elevating this theme was Chen Rong (c. 1200–1266), a Southern Song scholar-official renowned for his "ink dragons," which captured the creatures' ethereal power through bold brushwork, splattered ink for mist and clouds, and dramatic compositions evoking movement and symbiosis with nature. His works, such as the 1244 handscroll Nine Dragons, show nine dragons twisting through waves, rocks, and clouds, symbolizing prosperity and the cyclical forces of the universe—often used in rain-summoning rituals to invoke agricultural abundance.
Other examples include Five Dragons, where violent dragons stir waterfalls amid rainclouds, emphasizing their role in ecological balance, and Eleven Dragons, a handscroll highlighting their majestic, cloud-breathing forms.
Dragons also appeared alongside tigers in yin-yang pairings, as in Fachang Muqi's Dragon; Tiger, representing complementary opposites in a misty, contemplative style. Beyond painting, the motif adorned ceramics, lacquerware, and bronzes, reinforcing prosperity and protection in everyday and imperial contexts. This enduring theme influenced later dynasties, blending mysticism with cultural identity.
Six Dragons handscroll attributed to Chen Rong, from the Fujita Museum sold for $48,967,500 against high estimate of $1.8m #AsianArtWeek pic.twitter.com/rbMbIyub5P
— Christie's (@ChristiesInc) March 15, 2017
Ge Zhichuan Relocating by WANG MENG
1
1350 Ge Zhichuan Relocating by Wang Meng
2011 SOLD for RMB 400M by Poly
The Chinese culture comes from a very strong literary tradition mixed with mysticism. In the 11th century CE, Mi Fu opened the way to the themes of the literate landscape, and for several centuries the graphic arts were often devoted to these ancient stories.
A maternal grandson of Zhao Mengfu, Wang Meng is one of the four great literati masters of the Yuan dynasty. He incorporated the techniques of Tang and Song dynasties. He survived the Yuan but was accused to support a rebellion against the Ming emperor and died in jail.
In the theme of the immensity of nature contemplated by the sage, Wang practiced two opposite styles in a single artwork. The human dwellings and occupationals are rendered in a sharp drawing of very thin brushstroke. The lush surrounding of trees and mountains provides the feeling of infinity in a very dense texture. The bare rocks escape the realism for providing an unbalanced emotion.
On June 4, 2011, Poly sold for RMB 400M a hanging scroll painted in ink and wash circa 1350 CE by Wang Meng on the theme of the migration of Ge Hong to the sacred mountains. The provenance of this artwork has been established over six centuries. The image is shared by Wikimedia.
Ge Hong, also named Ge Zhichuan, lived 1,000 years before Wang in the Eastern Jin dynasty. Nicknamed the Little Immortal Old Man, he was an alchemist, a doctor and above all a Taoist master. He was going to study the secrets of immortality in the Luofu mountains. He stayed there for eight years. The image by Wang shows Ge and his suite passing through a valley under a very rocky landscape. Seven poems have been added.
asked to Grok :
Compare with the version kept in the Palace Museum, Beijing.
Grok thought :
The painting "Ge Zhichuan Relocating" (also known as "Zhichuan Resettlement") by Yuan Dynasty artist Wang Meng (c. 1308–1385) was sold at the Beijing Poly Auction on June 4, 2011, for RMB 402.5 million (approximately US$62.1 million), setting a record at the time for the most expensive Chinese artwork sold at auction. This hanging scroll, created circa 1350 in ink wash on paper, depicts the Eastern Jin Dynasty scholar and alchemist Ge Hong (styled Zhichuan) relocating his dwelling to Luofu Mountain to pursue alchemy. The work originated from a private collection and reflects Wang Meng's characteristic style of intricate, layered landscapes that evoke a sense of utopian freedom and scholarly introspection. No specific dimensions are publicly documented for this version, and it has been preserved through centuries of private ownership before the sale.
The Palace Museum in Beijing holds another version of the painting, titled "Ge Zhichuan Moving to the Mountains" (or "Ge Zhichuan Relocating"), dated to around the 1360s or 1370. This hanging scroll measures 139 x 58 cm and is executed in ink and colors on paper. It similarly portrays Ge Hong's relocation amid a mountainous landscape, showcasing Wang Meng's mastery of dense, textured brushwork to create a harmonious yet complex natural scene.
Both explore the same theme of Ge Hong's relocation, employing Wang Meng's signature complex brushwork to convey philosophical retreat into nature. They share motifs like winding paths, scholars, and enveloping mountains symbolizing escape from worldly chaos.
The earlier date of Poly's version suggests it may represent a formative stage in the artist's exploration of the theme; potentially more monochromatic and austere.
For the Palace Museum version, later creation with documented use of colors, possibly showing refined techniques from Wang Meng's evolving style; larger documented size and institutional preservation allow for extensive academic analysis.
These are distinct works on the same subject, not copies of each other, highlighting Wang Meng's recurring interest in this narrative as one of the "Four Masters of the Yuan Dynasty." The Poly version's high auction value underscores the market demand for rare private examples, while the Palace version remains a cornerstone for public study of Yuan landscape painting.
A maternal grandson of Zhao Mengfu, Wang Meng is one of the four great literati masters of the Yuan dynasty. He incorporated the techniques of Tang and Song dynasties. He survived the Yuan but was accused to support a rebellion against the Ming emperor and died in jail.
In the theme of the immensity of nature contemplated by the sage, Wang practiced two opposite styles in a single artwork. The human dwellings and occupationals are rendered in a sharp drawing of very thin brushstroke. The lush surrounding of trees and mountains provides the feeling of infinity in a very dense texture. The bare rocks escape the realism for providing an unbalanced emotion.
On June 4, 2011, Poly sold for RMB 400M a hanging scroll painted in ink and wash circa 1350 CE by Wang Meng on the theme of the migration of Ge Hong to the sacred mountains. The provenance of this artwork has been established over six centuries. The image is shared by Wikimedia.
Ge Hong, also named Ge Zhichuan, lived 1,000 years before Wang in the Eastern Jin dynasty. Nicknamed the Little Immortal Old Man, he was an alchemist, a doctor and above all a Taoist master. He was going to study the secrets of immortality in the Luofu mountains. He stayed there for eight years. The image by Wang shows Ge and his suite passing through a valley under a very rocky landscape. Seven poems have been added.
asked to Grok :
Compare with the version kept in the Palace Museum, Beijing.
Grok thought :
The painting "Ge Zhichuan Relocating" (also known as "Zhichuan Resettlement") by Yuan Dynasty artist Wang Meng (c. 1308–1385) was sold at the Beijing Poly Auction on June 4, 2011, for RMB 402.5 million (approximately US$62.1 million), setting a record at the time for the most expensive Chinese artwork sold at auction. This hanging scroll, created circa 1350 in ink wash on paper, depicts the Eastern Jin Dynasty scholar and alchemist Ge Hong (styled Zhichuan) relocating his dwelling to Luofu Mountain to pursue alchemy. The work originated from a private collection and reflects Wang Meng's characteristic style of intricate, layered landscapes that evoke a sense of utopian freedom and scholarly introspection. No specific dimensions are publicly documented for this version, and it has been preserved through centuries of private ownership before the sale.
The Palace Museum in Beijing holds another version of the painting, titled "Ge Zhichuan Moving to the Mountains" (or "Ge Zhichuan Relocating"), dated to around the 1360s or 1370. This hanging scroll measures 139 x 58 cm and is executed in ink and colors on paper. It similarly portrays Ge Hong's relocation amid a mountainous landscape, showcasing Wang Meng's mastery of dense, textured brushwork to create a harmonious yet complex natural scene.
Both explore the same theme of Ge Hong's relocation, employing Wang Meng's signature complex brushwork to convey philosophical retreat into nature. They share motifs like winding paths, scholars, and enveloping mountains symbolizing escape from worldly chaos.
The earlier date of Poly's version suggests it may represent a formative stage in the artist's exploration of the theme; potentially more monochromatic and austere.
For the Palace Museum version, later creation with documented use of colors, possibly showing refined techniques from Wang Meng's evolving style; larger documented size and institutional preservation allow for extensive academic analysis.
These are distinct works on the same subject, not copies of each other, highlighting Wang Meng's recurring interest in this narrative as one of the "Four Masters of the Yuan Dynasty." The Poly version's high auction value underscores the market demand for rare private examples, while the Palace version remains a cornerstone for public study of Yuan landscape painting.
1 bis
masterpiece
1360
Palace Museum, Beijing
The Palace Museum in Beijing has a 139 x 58 cm scroll by the same artist on the same theme, dated around 1360, with another landscape in an oblique perspective.
The image is shared by Wikimedia.
The image is shared by Wikimedia.
Buddhist Thangka presented by the Yongle Emperor
2014 SOLD for HK$ 350M by Christie's
Hongwu had founded the Ming Dynasty by relying upon Buddhist sects. His fourth son, the Prince of Yan, was an able and competent general. Too competent indeed : the old emperor found a subterfuge for removing him from the rule of succession.
The Prince took power in a coup four years later, 1402 in our calendar. His nephew, who perished in the fire of the imperial palace after having revived the feudal war, was scholar minded and supported by the Confucians. The new emperor erased from the annals the reign of his predecessor of whom he massacred the followers, took the name Yongle meaning Perpetual Happiness and immediately began to prepare for the transfer of the capital from Nanking to Beijing.
The ambitious Yongle could not appear as a usurper : he offered to himself a Buddhist legitimacy. He invited the Karmapa, who was one of the most important sages of Tibetan Buddhism and got his power through reincarnation.
The trip of the Karmapa from Tibet to Nanking lasted four years, during which Yongle organized the Buddhist tribute to his deceased parents and prepared lavish gifts. The stories of miracles performed by the Karmapa were propagated and contributed effectively to assure the power of Yongle, now firmly established as Hongwu's heir.
On November 26, 2014, Christie's sold for HK $ 350M a wonderful silk thangka embroidered with silk and gold threads, lot 3001. This monumental piece 3.35 x 2.13 m is in perfect condition with bright colors of great beauty.
According to the concerns of Yongle, its theme is the victory over death. The central character with a bright red head is Raktayamari, the Conqueror of Death, who embraces his wife and mercilessly tramples the blue body of Yama the Lord of Death lying on the back of a buffalo. The top and bottom of the image display some deities inviting to Buddhist devotion.
This piece includes the presentation mark of Yongle. The existence of two thangkas of same quality in a monastery in Lhasa along with the fact that the thangka for sale was in Sikkim in the 1940s reinforces the assumption that it had actually accompanied the Karmapa in his return trip.
Grok thought :
Quote
Christie's @ChristiesInc Nov 26, 2014
This 15th c. thangka has sold for HK$348,400,000 (US$45m), a #worldauctionrecord for a Chinese work of art.
The Prince took power in a coup four years later, 1402 in our calendar. His nephew, who perished in the fire of the imperial palace after having revived the feudal war, was scholar minded and supported by the Confucians. The new emperor erased from the annals the reign of his predecessor of whom he massacred the followers, took the name Yongle meaning Perpetual Happiness and immediately began to prepare for the transfer of the capital from Nanking to Beijing.
The ambitious Yongle could not appear as a usurper : he offered to himself a Buddhist legitimacy. He invited the Karmapa, who was one of the most important sages of Tibetan Buddhism and got his power through reincarnation.
The trip of the Karmapa from Tibet to Nanking lasted four years, during which Yongle organized the Buddhist tribute to his deceased parents and prepared lavish gifts. The stories of miracles performed by the Karmapa were propagated and contributed effectively to assure the power of Yongle, now firmly established as Hongwu's heir.
On November 26, 2014, Christie's sold for HK $ 350M a wonderful silk thangka embroidered with silk and gold threads, lot 3001. This monumental piece 3.35 x 2.13 m is in perfect condition with bright colors of great beauty.
According to the concerns of Yongle, its theme is the victory over death. The central character with a bright red head is Raktayamari, the Conqueror of Death, who embraces his wife and mercilessly tramples the blue body of Yama the Lord of Death lying on the back of a buffalo. The top and bottom of the image display some deities inviting to Buddhist devotion.
This piece includes the presentation mark of Yongle. The existence of two thangkas of same quality in a monastery in Lhasa along with the fact that the thangka for sale was in Sikkim in the 1940s reinforces the assumption that it had actually accompanied the Karmapa in his return trip.
Grok thought :
Quote
Christie's @ChristiesInc Nov 26, 2014
This 15th c. thangka has sold for HK$348,400,000 (US$45m), a #worldauctionrecord for a Chinese work of art.
- The post announces a record-breaking sale at Christie's Hong Kong on November 25, 2014, of a Ming Dynasty (Yongle period, 1402–1424) embroidered silk thangka depicting Yama, the Tibetan Buddhist lord of death, for HK$348.4 million (US$45 million), surpassing prior benchmarks for Chinese art.
- Acquired by Chinese billionaire Liu Yiqian for his Long Museum in Shanghai, the artifact reflects the 2014 boom in the Chinese art market, where imperial Buddhist works symbolized cultural prestige and drove auction prices to unprecedented levels.
- The attached image reveals the thangka's masterful embroidery—over 200,000 stitches in silk threads on satin—featuring Yama's multi-armed red form riding a buffalo amid attendants, blending Tibetan iconography with Ming imperial craftsmanship for ritual use.
The Yongle embroidered silk thangka, sold as lot 3001 at Christie's Hong Kong on November 26, 2014, is a monumental imperial work (approximately 336 x 214 cm) from the Yongle period (1402–1424) of the Ming dynasty. It bears a six-character Yongle presentation mark in couched gold thread and achieved a record price of around HK$348 million (about US$45 million), purchased by Chinese collector Liu Yiqian; it is now in the Long Museum, Shanghai.
Theme and specific symbols: The central deity is Raktayamari (Red Yamari or "Red Killer of Death"), a wrathful tantric form of the Bodhisattva Manjusri (associated with Amitabha Buddha's red family). He is depicted in yab-yum (union) embrace with his consort Vajravetali (paler red), standing atop the corpse of Yama (Lord of Death, dark blue) lying face-down on a buffalo, all on a multicolored lotus pedestal. This symbolizes the conquest of death, suffering, and the maras (demonic obstacles). Key symbols include:
Assumption about weaving/embroidery location: It was almost certainly produced in imperial workshops in the Jiangnan region, likely Nanjing (the early Ming capital under Yongle), where the court maintained advanced silk manufactories (e.g., the Hall of Divine Silk) with high-density jiang chou silk grounds and sophisticated dyeing. This is inferred from the technical mastery in silk handling, the jiang chou fabric type (sturdy paired-warps from Jiangnan traditions), and historical records of Nanjing-based textile production for court and diplomatic use; Hangzhou influences are possible, but Nanjing aligns with the court's relocation and workshop organization before the capital moved to Beijing.
Technical breakthrough: The embroidery represents a pinnacle of early Ming textile innovation, mobilizing immense resources for scale, detail, and preservation. Key advancements include:
Theme and specific symbols: The central deity is Raktayamari (Red Yamari or "Red Killer of Death"), a wrathful tantric form of the Bodhisattva Manjusri (associated with Amitabha Buddha's red family). He is depicted in yab-yum (union) embrace with his consort Vajravetali (paler red), standing atop the corpse of Yama (Lord of Death, dark blue) lying face-down on a buffalo, all on a multicolored lotus pedestal. This symbolizes the conquest of death, suffering, and the maras (demonic obstacles). Key symbols include:
- Red body: Boon of longevity and overcoming maras.
- Three red eyes: Compassion across time (past, present, future).
- Khatvanga staff (right hand): Subduing afflictions.
- Kapala skull cup (left): Transforming poisons/essences.
- Crown of five dry skulls: Five poisons into five wisdoms.
- Necklace of 50 heads: Sanskrit alphabet (vowels/consonants).
- Eight nagas/snakes: Subduing obstacles.
- Tiger skin: Frightening violent dispositions.
- Flames: Non-conceptual pristine awareness/wisdom.
- Sun/moon discs: Enlightenment thoughts. Surrounding elements include the Five Dhyani Buddhas (upper row), Manjusri and Heruka Vajrabhairava, Green and White Tara (for protection/longevity), and seven dancing offering goddesses (representing seven of the eight traditional offerings: water, flowers, incense, lamp, perfume, food; music omitted). The background features dense Indian-lotus scrolls on green ground, with a vajra-bordered yellow band.
Assumption about weaving/embroidery location: It was almost certainly produced in imperial workshops in the Jiangnan region, likely Nanjing (the early Ming capital under Yongle), where the court maintained advanced silk manufactories (e.g., the Hall of Divine Silk) with high-density jiang chou silk grounds and sophisticated dyeing. This is inferred from the technical mastery in silk handling, the jiang chou fabric type (sturdy paired-warps from Jiangnan traditions), and historical records of Nanjing-based textile production for court and diplomatic use; Hangzhou influences are possible, but Nanjing aligns with the court's relocation and workshop organization before the capital moved to Beijing.
Technical breakthrough: The embroidery represents a pinnacle of early Ming textile innovation, mobilizing immense resources for scale, detail, and preservation. Key advancements include:
- Use of regular long-and-short stitches (typically irregular for figures) to create a textured, painterly effect with horizontal striations resembling pile.
- Concentric oval shading in gradual tones for musculature and highlights.
- Couching of gold-wrapped threads for outlines, details, and the imperial mark.
- Over 14 shades/colors (e.g., lotus petals in multi-shade transitions per hue) via advanced dyeing.
- High-weft-density jiang chou silk ground to support heavy stitching without sagging.
- Lasuo stitches for patterns, diaper motifs on garments, and subtle flame gradations with multi-ply threads. These techniques achieve a luminous, durable result (silk retains luster after 600+ years), surpassing earlier Yuan examples in refinement and scale for ritual/diplomatic art.
Tibetan Thangka Sold for $45 Million at Christie’shttp://t.co/cQTe7JBwGu pic.twitter.com/UntjeBOGEz
— ARTINFO HongKong (@ARTINFOHongKong) November 26, 2014
1610 Lingbi Stone by Wu Bin
2020 SOLD for RMB 510M by Poly
The gongshi is the rock of the literati. The erosion of the limestone has created strange shapes, simulating twisted columns rising to the sky. The larger ones are beloved ornaments in Chinese gardens. Lingbi, in Anshan province, is one of the three main deposits.
Mi Wanzhong, a painter and calligrapher, is a passionate collector whose artist name is Youshi, the friend of stones. Around 1610 CE he acquires an extraordinary Lingbi stone 50 cm high, simulating a forest with spectacular shrinkages and branches. He considers his artistic skills to be inadequate and calls his friend Wu Bin.
Wu Bin studies the stone for a month. His ten drawings display the specimen from all angles, with great precision of line and beautiful contrasts providing a superb texture effect. Each image is flanked by text.
Each of the ten elements measures 55 x 115 cm, for a total uninterrupted length of 11.5 m. The handscroll also includes two introductions respectively 26 x 112 cm and 48 x 143 cm and an epilogue 55 cm x 11.3 m with colophons.
Ten Views of a Lingbi Stone was sold for RMB 510M by Poly on October 18, 2020, lot 3922, after nearly an hour of bidding. It is illustrated with some enlarged details in the post sale report published by The Value. Please watch the much detailed video shared by Norton Museum of Art.
The Lingbi stone which served as a model only survived the ravages of time for a few decades.
Grok thought :
Quote
Economic Daily, China @EDNewsChina Oct 19, 2020
Can you believe it? A painting can be sold for 500 mln yuan! At the 15th anniversary celebration of #Beijing Poly International #Auction, the painting of Chinese painter Wu Bin is sold for 512.9 mln yuan, becoming the most expensive ancient painting and calligraphy in the world
During the Ming dynasty (1368–1644), the collection and appreciation of scholar's rocks, known as gongshi or guai shi (strange stones), reached its zenith among the literati class. Lingbi stones, sourced from Lingbi county in Anhui Province, were particularly coveted for their unique qualities: exceptional durability, resonant sound when struck (often described as metallic or jade-like), aesthetic beauty derived from their dark, glossy surfaces, and intricate natural formations featuring wrinkles, perforations, and bizarre shapes that evoked miniature landscapes or sacred mountains. These attributes made them symbols of primordial cosmic energies, embodying the enduring virtues of nature, longevity, and scholarly refinement.
Wu Bin's handscroll Ten Views of a Lingbi Stone (1610), sold as lot 3922 at Poly Auction on October 18, 2020, for RMB 512.9 million, serves as a quintessential artifact illustrating this cultural phenomenon. The nearly 28-meter-long ink-on-paper work, created by the Fujian-born painter and devout Buddhist Wu Bin (ca. 1543–ca. 1626), depicts a single Lingbi stone from ten distinct angles, using meticulous brushwork and subtle washes to capture its jagged, flame-like contours and dynamic, transformative essence. Commissioned by the stone's owner, the prominent collector and official Mi Wanzhong (1570–1628), the scroll not only documents the rock but elevates it through Wu's accompanying calligraphy and poetic inscriptions, treating it as a subject worthy of profound artistic exploration. Mi reportedly acquired this specific stone after a lengthy search and at great personal expense, underscoring the obsessive passion that drove Ming collectors.
This fascination stemmed from broader intellectual and aesthetic trends in Ming society. Literati viewed such stones as microcosms of the universe, infused with the same vital forces (qi) that shaped mountains and the cosmos, drawing from ancient Daoist and Confucian ideas of harmony with nature. Collecting peaked in the late Ming, fueled by economic prosperity, urbanization, and a scholarly retreat from political turmoil into private gardens and studios. Stones like Lingbi were displayed indoors or in gardens, often on custom pedestals, and inspired poetry, paintings, and even illustrated treatises on connoisseurship. Their value rivaled that of fine artworks or real estate, with collectors like Mi equating them to sacred objects capable of evoking supernatural qualities, such as emitting clouds or promoting health. Wu Bin's multi-perspective portrayal in the handscroll mirrors this craze by attempting to fully encapsulate the stone's elusive spirit, much like how scholars ritually "viewed" rocks from various angles to appreciate their infinite facets.
The tradition built on earlier dynasties—Tang poets like Bo Juyi celebrated similar rocks, while Song emperors like Huizong amassed collections and figures like Mi Fu famously "bowed" to stones—but Ming enthusiasts amplified it into a sophisticated cultural practice. Wu Bin's work, with its panoramic and almost reverential documentation, thus encapsulates how Lingbi stones transcended mere objects to become emblems of elite taste and philosophical contemplation in Ming China.
Mi Wanzhong, a painter and calligrapher, is a passionate collector whose artist name is Youshi, the friend of stones. Around 1610 CE he acquires an extraordinary Lingbi stone 50 cm high, simulating a forest with spectacular shrinkages and branches. He considers his artistic skills to be inadequate and calls his friend Wu Bin.
Wu Bin studies the stone for a month. His ten drawings display the specimen from all angles, with great precision of line and beautiful contrasts providing a superb texture effect. Each image is flanked by text.
Each of the ten elements measures 55 x 115 cm, for a total uninterrupted length of 11.5 m. The handscroll also includes two introductions respectively 26 x 112 cm and 48 x 143 cm and an epilogue 55 cm x 11.3 m with colophons.
Ten Views of a Lingbi Stone was sold for RMB 510M by Poly on October 18, 2020, lot 3922, after nearly an hour of bidding. It is illustrated with some enlarged details in the post sale report published by The Value. Please watch the much detailed video shared by Norton Museum of Art.
The Lingbi stone which served as a model only survived the ravages of time for a few decades.
Grok thought :
Quote
Economic Daily, China @EDNewsChina Oct 19, 2020
Can you believe it? A painting can be sold for 500 mln yuan! At the 15th anniversary celebration of #Beijing Poly International #Auction, the painting of Chinese painter Wu Bin is sold for 512.9 mln yuan, becoming the most expensive ancient painting and calligraphy in the world
- The post announces the 2020 sale of Ming Dynasty artist Wu Bin's 27-meter handscroll "Ten Views of a Fantastic Rock" for 512.9 million yuan ($77 million) at Beijing Poly Auction, setting a world record for ancient Chinese painting and calligraphy at the time.
- Wu Bin, active in the late 16th century, specialized in surreal ink depictions of Lingbi stones—resonant scholar's rocks prized in Chinese culture for their auditory and aesthetic qualities, blending calligraphy and landscape in literati tradition.
- Despite a 2025 calligraphy sale by Rao Jie fetching $32 million, Wu Bin's work holds as the most expensive ancient Chinese painting auctioned, highlighting sustained global interest in Ming-era art amid China's booming art market.
During the Ming dynasty (1368–1644), the collection and appreciation of scholar's rocks, known as gongshi or guai shi (strange stones), reached its zenith among the literati class. Lingbi stones, sourced from Lingbi county in Anhui Province, were particularly coveted for their unique qualities: exceptional durability, resonant sound when struck (often described as metallic or jade-like), aesthetic beauty derived from their dark, glossy surfaces, and intricate natural formations featuring wrinkles, perforations, and bizarre shapes that evoked miniature landscapes or sacred mountains. These attributes made them symbols of primordial cosmic energies, embodying the enduring virtues of nature, longevity, and scholarly refinement.
Wu Bin's handscroll Ten Views of a Lingbi Stone (1610), sold as lot 3922 at Poly Auction on October 18, 2020, for RMB 512.9 million, serves as a quintessential artifact illustrating this cultural phenomenon. The nearly 28-meter-long ink-on-paper work, created by the Fujian-born painter and devout Buddhist Wu Bin (ca. 1543–ca. 1626), depicts a single Lingbi stone from ten distinct angles, using meticulous brushwork and subtle washes to capture its jagged, flame-like contours and dynamic, transformative essence. Commissioned by the stone's owner, the prominent collector and official Mi Wanzhong (1570–1628), the scroll not only documents the rock but elevates it through Wu's accompanying calligraphy and poetic inscriptions, treating it as a subject worthy of profound artistic exploration. Mi reportedly acquired this specific stone after a lengthy search and at great personal expense, underscoring the obsessive passion that drove Ming collectors.
This fascination stemmed from broader intellectual and aesthetic trends in Ming society. Literati viewed such stones as microcosms of the universe, infused with the same vital forces (qi) that shaped mountains and the cosmos, drawing from ancient Daoist and Confucian ideas of harmony with nature. Collecting peaked in the late Ming, fueled by economic prosperity, urbanization, and a scholarly retreat from political turmoil into private gardens and studios. Stones like Lingbi were displayed indoors or in gardens, often on custom pedestals, and inspired poetry, paintings, and even illustrated treatises on connoisseurship. Their value rivaled that of fine artworks or real estate, with collectors like Mi equating them to sacred objects capable of evoking supernatural qualities, such as emitting clouds or promoting health. Wu Bin's multi-perspective portrayal in the handscroll mirrors this craze by attempting to fully encapsulate the stone's elusive spirit, much like how scholars ritually "viewed" rocks from various angles to appreciate their infinite facets.
The tradition built on earlier dynasties—Tang poets like Bo Juyi celebrated similar rocks, while Song emperors like Huizong amassed collections and figures like Mi Fu famously "bowed" to stones—but Ming enthusiasts amplified it into a sophisticated cultural practice. Wu Bin's work, with its panoramic and almost reverential documentation, thus encapsulates how Lingbi stones transcended mere objects to become emblems of elite taste and philosophical contemplation in Ming China.
Details on Ten Views of a Lingbi Stone
Wu Bin's Ten Views of a Lingbi Stone (also known as Ten Views of a Lingbi Rock) is a monumental handscroll painting created in 1610 during the Ming dynasty's Wanli reign (1573–1620). Executed in ink on paper by the artist Wu Bin (c. 1543–c. 1626), a professional painter and devout Buddhist known for his eccentric landscapes and figure works, the scroll measures approximately 27 meters in length when fully unrolled, making it one of the longest surviving Chinese handscrolls. It depicts a single Lingbi stone—a type of limestone scholar's rock prized for its resonant sound, dark glossy surface, and bizarre natural formations—from ten distinct angles, capturing its intricate peaks, veins, perforations, and flame-like contours with meticulous brushwork and subtle tonal washes. The stone itself, sourced from Lingbi county in Anhui Province, was about 63.7 cm tall in reality but rendered slightly smaller at around 51 cm in the painting for proportional accuracy. Each view is presented sequentially: front, back, sides, diagonals, and even bottoms, with the tenth view featuring Wu's signature to signify completion. The artwork includes detailed inscriptions with measurements (e.g., the middle peak at 1 chi 7 cun) and poetic colophons by contemporaries like Dong Qichang and Chen Jiru, as well as later Qing dynasty figures, enhancing its documentary and literary value.
The creation process was intensive and meditative. Commissioned by Mi Wanzhong (1570–1628), a high-ranking official, calligrapher, and avid collector who acquired the stone after a prolonged search, Wu Bin spent a full month examining the rock in Mi's Beijing studio, merging his consciousness with it through repetitive observation. This allowed him to exhaustively depict its multifaceted form, shifting from objective representation to an expressive negation of its physicality, where the painting itself assumes the stone's presence. Mi's account praises Wu's skill in scaling and reconstructing the stone, akin to early photogrammetry, while the process reflects late Ming empirical interests in mineralogy and perceptual sciences.
Historically and culturally, the handscroll epitomizes the Ming dynasty's obsession with scholar's rocks (gongshi), which were collected by literati as microcosms of the universe, embodying primordial energies (qi) and capable of magical transformations like emitting clouds, predicting weather, or healing. Lingbi stones, in particular, were revered for their durability and jade-like resonance, symbolizing Daoist and Buddhist ideals of harmony, illusion, and enlightenment. The work fits into the era's "wanshang" collecting culture, where such objects and their depictions constructed personal realities amid political turmoil and intellectual syncretism between Confucianism, Daoism, and resurgent Buddhism. Philosophically, it draws from Yogācāra Buddhism, revived in late Ming China, viewing perception as worldmaking: the ten views symbolize comprehensive vision transcending sensory limits, evoking concepts like the ten directions in Buddhist cosmology and meditative practices from the Śūraṅgama Sūtra to realize ultimate reality beyond illusion. It parallels Yangming Confucianism's mind-object relations, where phenomena manifest from consciousness, and incorporates Tathāgatagarbha ideas for soteriological depth.
In terms of ownership and market history, the scroll has a notable provenance. It was exhibited in Beijing, Nanjing, and Fujian during the Ming and Qing periods, accumulating colophons from elite scholars. In modern times, it became the first Chinese painting to sell for over a million dollars at Sotheby's in December 1989. More recently, it fetched a record RMB 512.9 million (approximately USD 77.1 million) at Poly Auction in Beijing on October 18, 2020, as lot 3922, marking one of the highest prices for a classical Chinese artwork.
The handscroll has been featured in major exhibitions, most prominently "Wu Bin: Ten Views of a Lingbi Stone" at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art (LACMA)'s Resnick Pavilion from December 10, 2017, to June 24, 2018. This show contextualized the painting alongside actual Lingbi and Taihu stones, contemporary ink paintings, and explored the broader history of stone collecting in China, tying it to Daoist cosmology and classical poetry. Its enduring significance lies in elevating a natural object to profound artistic and philosophical status, making it a landmark of Chinese art history and the most extraordinary depiction of a stone ever created.
Wu Bin's Ten Views of a Lingbi Stone (also known as Ten Views of a Lingbi Rock) is a monumental handscroll painting created in 1610 during the Ming dynasty's Wanli reign (1573–1620). Executed in ink on paper by the artist Wu Bin (c. 1543–c. 1626), a professional painter and devout Buddhist known for his eccentric landscapes and figure works, the scroll measures approximately 27 meters in length when fully unrolled, making it one of the longest surviving Chinese handscrolls. It depicts a single Lingbi stone—a type of limestone scholar's rock prized for its resonant sound, dark glossy surface, and bizarre natural formations—from ten distinct angles, capturing its intricate peaks, veins, perforations, and flame-like contours with meticulous brushwork and subtle tonal washes. The stone itself, sourced from Lingbi county in Anhui Province, was about 63.7 cm tall in reality but rendered slightly smaller at around 51 cm in the painting for proportional accuracy. Each view is presented sequentially: front, back, sides, diagonals, and even bottoms, with the tenth view featuring Wu's signature to signify completion. The artwork includes detailed inscriptions with measurements (e.g., the middle peak at 1 chi 7 cun) and poetic colophons by contemporaries like Dong Qichang and Chen Jiru, as well as later Qing dynasty figures, enhancing its documentary and literary value.
The creation process was intensive and meditative. Commissioned by Mi Wanzhong (1570–1628), a high-ranking official, calligrapher, and avid collector who acquired the stone after a prolonged search, Wu Bin spent a full month examining the rock in Mi's Beijing studio, merging his consciousness with it through repetitive observation. This allowed him to exhaustively depict its multifaceted form, shifting from objective representation to an expressive negation of its physicality, where the painting itself assumes the stone's presence. Mi's account praises Wu's skill in scaling and reconstructing the stone, akin to early photogrammetry, while the process reflects late Ming empirical interests in mineralogy and perceptual sciences.
Historically and culturally, the handscroll epitomizes the Ming dynasty's obsession with scholar's rocks (gongshi), which were collected by literati as microcosms of the universe, embodying primordial energies (qi) and capable of magical transformations like emitting clouds, predicting weather, or healing. Lingbi stones, in particular, were revered for their durability and jade-like resonance, symbolizing Daoist and Buddhist ideals of harmony, illusion, and enlightenment. The work fits into the era's "wanshang" collecting culture, where such objects and their depictions constructed personal realities amid political turmoil and intellectual syncretism between Confucianism, Daoism, and resurgent Buddhism. Philosophically, it draws from Yogācāra Buddhism, revived in late Ming China, viewing perception as worldmaking: the ten views symbolize comprehensive vision transcending sensory limits, evoking concepts like the ten directions in Buddhist cosmology and meditative practices from the Śūraṅgama Sūtra to realize ultimate reality beyond illusion. It parallels Yangming Confucianism's mind-object relations, where phenomena manifest from consciousness, and incorporates Tathāgatagarbha ideas for soteriological depth.
In terms of ownership and market history, the scroll has a notable provenance. It was exhibited in Beijing, Nanjing, and Fujian during the Ming and Qing periods, accumulating colophons from elite scholars. In modern times, it became the first Chinese painting to sell for over a million dollars at Sotheby's in December 1989. More recently, it fetched a record RMB 512.9 million (approximately USD 77.1 million) at Poly Auction in Beijing on October 18, 2020, as lot 3922, marking one of the highest prices for a classical Chinese artwork.
The handscroll has been featured in major exhibitions, most prominently "Wu Bin: Ten Views of a Lingbi Stone" at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art (LACMA)'s Resnick Pavilion from December 10, 2017, to June 24, 2018. This show contextualized the painting alongside actual Lingbi and Taihu stones, contemporary ink paintings, and explored the broader history of stone collecting in China, tying it to Daoist cosmology and classical poetry. Its enduring significance lies in elevating a natural object to profound artistic and philosophical status, making it a landmark of Chinese art history and the most extraordinary depiction of a stone ever created.
Can you believe it? A painting can be sold for 500 mln yuan! At the 15th anniversary celebration of #Beijing Poly International #Auction, the painting of Chinese painter Wu Bin is sold for 512.9 mln yuan, becoming the most expensive ancient painting and calligraphy in the world□ pic.twitter.com/N8Pr46VEnB
— Economic Daily, China (@EDNewsChina) October 19, 2020
1743 Qianlong reticulated vase
2010 UNPAID at £ 43M plus a buyer's premium of £ 8.6M, by Bainbridges
In 1728 CE, Tang Ying is appointed by the Yongzheng emperor as the Superintendent of the Imperial porcelain produced at Jingdezhen. He spends several years observing the best practices of the potters. One of his first major successes is the development of the yangcai, offering a less expensive substitute to the Imperial City's falangcai that remains the high end.
These first years are experimental, with pieces of all shapes. Qianlong who succeeds Yongzheng in 1735 CE is just as demanding as his father. To please him, they must constantly bring novelties that match his ambitious role as Son of Heaven, accumulating the styles of all dynasties and integrating the new European trends.
In the early 1740s Tang Ying's expertise in Jingdezhen has no limits. The most complicated pieces are technological syntheses that require a long succession of firings at the risk of a low yield.
In a memorandum submitted to Qianlong in 1743 CE, Tang Ying apologizes for the small amount of units produced in the new style of double vase, only nine. The inner part is enclosed in the outer vase with a distance of about 3 to 4 cm between their walls. The outer vase is pierced by large holes of various elegant shapes that allow the peeping to the inner part. The exterior is decorated with the same profusion as more classical imperial pieces.
Qianlong does not request the impossible. He authorizes to complete in pairs those models that had been produced in single pieces before suspending this technique sine die.
A reticulated vase with pairs of fishes surfaced in Middlesex in 2010. 40 cm high, it mixes archaic, Song, Buddhist and rocaille inspirations, juxtaposing the classic celadon and the modern yangcai in a yellow ground with sgraffiato. The inner wall is a blue and white in Ming style. After 30 minutes of bidding, Bainbridges's hammer fell at £ 43M, £ 51.6M including the premium, but the payment failed and the sale was cancelled. Here is the link to the 2012 report by The Telegraph before the sale was cancelled.
In 2010 nobody had considered the catalog of the exhibition in New York in 1905 of a Japanese collection where its pairing piece had been photographed and described. This vase has resurfaced. It was sold for HK $ 150M from a lower estimate of HK $ 50M by Sotheby's on October 3, 2018, lot 3001. It differs from the Middlesex specimen by a rarer variant of the reign mark and so may be the master item produced for that pair.
Detailed Description by Grok :
Bainbridges Vase (Lot 800, 2010)
Description & Form
Double-walled reticulated vase with famille rose enameling; pierced body featuring four gilt-rimmed medallions with twin fish (symbolizing marital harmony) among waves, lotus scrolls, and chilong dragons in shaded iron-red on a gilt ground; flared neck and foot with key-fret borders; height 41 cm.
Decoration & Technique
Famille rose enamels with shaded iron-red and gilt details; reticulated band with blue enamel borders; inner wall possibly with related fish motifs (per catalog comparables). Focuses on marine and floral motifs for harmony and abundance.
Provenance & History
Discovered in 2010 during clearance of a Pinner, UK, home (former residence of Emily Newman, d. 2010); inherited by Tony Johnson and family. Attributed to Qianlong imperial kilns; no pre-20th-century provenance noted.
Auction Outcome
Hammer at £43 million, but cancelled; resold privately via Bonhams for ~£25 million in 2013 to a Far Eastern buyer.
Rarity & Significance
Rare yangcai reticulated "jiqingyouyu" (auspicious fish) type; comparables include blue-ground revolving vases in museums. Gained fame as the "Pinner Vase" for its dramatic story.
These first years are experimental, with pieces of all shapes. Qianlong who succeeds Yongzheng in 1735 CE is just as demanding as his father. To please him, they must constantly bring novelties that match his ambitious role as Son of Heaven, accumulating the styles of all dynasties and integrating the new European trends.
In the early 1740s Tang Ying's expertise in Jingdezhen has no limits. The most complicated pieces are technological syntheses that require a long succession of firings at the risk of a low yield.
In a memorandum submitted to Qianlong in 1743 CE, Tang Ying apologizes for the small amount of units produced in the new style of double vase, only nine. The inner part is enclosed in the outer vase with a distance of about 3 to 4 cm between their walls. The outer vase is pierced by large holes of various elegant shapes that allow the peeping to the inner part. The exterior is decorated with the same profusion as more classical imperial pieces.
Qianlong does not request the impossible. He authorizes to complete in pairs those models that had been produced in single pieces before suspending this technique sine die.
A reticulated vase with pairs of fishes surfaced in Middlesex in 2010. 40 cm high, it mixes archaic, Song, Buddhist and rocaille inspirations, juxtaposing the classic celadon and the modern yangcai in a yellow ground with sgraffiato. The inner wall is a blue and white in Ming style. After 30 minutes of bidding, Bainbridges's hammer fell at £ 43M, £ 51.6M including the premium, but the payment failed and the sale was cancelled. Here is the link to the 2012 report by The Telegraph before the sale was cancelled.
In 2010 nobody had considered the catalog of the exhibition in New York in 1905 of a Japanese collection where its pairing piece had been photographed and described. This vase has resurfaced. It was sold for HK $ 150M from a lower estimate of HK $ 50M by Sotheby's on October 3, 2018, lot 3001. It differs from the Middlesex specimen by a rarer variant of the reign mark and so may be the master item produced for that pair.
Detailed Description by Grok :
Bainbridges Vase (Lot 800, 2010)
Description & Form
Double-walled reticulated vase with famille rose enameling; pierced body featuring four gilt-rimmed medallions with twin fish (symbolizing marital harmony) among waves, lotus scrolls, and chilong dragons in shaded iron-red on a gilt ground; flared neck and foot with key-fret borders; height 41 cm.
Decoration & Technique
Famille rose enamels with shaded iron-red and gilt details; reticulated band with blue enamel borders; inner wall possibly with related fish motifs (per catalog comparables). Focuses on marine and floral motifs for harmony and abundance.
Provenance & History
Discovered in 2010 during clearance of a Pinner, UK, home (former residence of Emily Newman, d. 2010); inherited by Tony Johnson and family. Attributed to Qianlong imperial kilns; no pre-20th-century provenance noted.
Auction Outcome
Hammer at £43 million, but cancelled; resold privately via Bonhams for ~£25 million in 2013 to a Far Eastern buyer.
Rarity & Significance
Rare yangcai reticulated "jiqingyouyu" (auspicious fish) type; comparables include blue-ground revolving vases in museums. Gained fame as the "Pinner Vase" for its dramatic story.
The famous Qianlong reticulated vase associated with Bainbridge's auction in 2010, lot 800, is the iconic one discovered during a house clearance in Pinner, London. It was an 18th-century Qing dynasty porcelain vase from the Qianlong period (1736–1795), made for the imperial court.
This particular vase was a famille rose (fencai) decorated example with a pink ground, featuring intricate reticulated (openwork/pierced) panels, often with floral or auspicious motifs, and gilt details. It was consigned from a modest home where it had been stored in a box or loft for decades, initially undervalued or dismissed by some experts (including a BBC Antiques Roadshow appearance where it was called a clever reproduction).
At Bainbridge's auction house (a small family-run operation in Ruislip, Middlesex, UK) on November 11, 2010, lot 800 carried a modest pre-sale estimate (around £800–£1,200 or similar low figures in some reports, though it was presented with a realistic but still conservative valuation). Intense international bidding—driven heavily by Chinese collectors—drove the hammer price to £43 million (approximately $69 million at the time), plus buyer's premium, totaling around £53.1 million. This made it the most expensive Chinese work of art ever sold at auction at that point, and it held the record for several years.
However, the sale was unpaid (or "bought in"/failed to complete) by the underbidder or winning bidder in the immediate aftermath. The winning telephone bidder did not pay, leading to the vase not changing hands at that price. Reports indicate the seller did not receive payment for an extended period (some sources say nearly two years later issues persisted with commissions or disputes). The vase was later withdrawn or handled privately/through other channels, but the headline-grabbing £53m figure became legendary in the art world as a symbol of the booming Chinese art market around 2010.
Technical Breakthrough
The vase exemplifies the peak of Qing imperial porcelain innovation under Emperor Qianlong, supervised by the celebrated superintendent Tang Ying (who oversaw the Jingdezhen kilns). Key breakthroughs include:
Legacy
This 2010 sale (despite the non-payment drama) sparked global fascination with Chinese imperial porcelain, fueling a massive surge in demand from mainland Chinese buyers during the early 2010s boom. It highlighted the shift of the high-end Chinese art market from London/New York to Hong Kong and Beijing.
The piece (or its close variants, like the "twin" Yamanaka reticulated vase sold at Sotheby's Hong Kong in 2018 for high sums) inspired renewed scholarly interest in Qianlong-era technical virtuosity. Reticulated yangcai vases remain among the most coveted and expensive categories in Chinese ceramics, with similar examples achieving multi-million-dollar results at major houses.
The story endures as a "rags-to-riches" auction fairytale—turning a dusty family heirloom into a record-breaker—while underscoring market volatility (unpaid bids, disputes) in overheated sectors.
This particular vase was a famille rose (fencai) decorated example with a pink ground, featuring intricate reticulated (openwork/pierced) panels, often with floral or auspicious motifs, and gilt details. It was consigned from a modest home where it had been stored in a box or loft for decades, initially undervalued or dismissed by some experts (including a BBC Antiques Roadshow appearance where it was called a clever reproduction).
At Bainbridge's auction house (a small family-run operation in Ruislip, Middlesex, UK) on November 11, 2010, lot 800 carried a modest pre-sale estimate (around £800–£1,200 or similar low figures in some reports, though it was presented with a realistic but still conservative valuation). Intense international bidding—driven heavily by Chinese collectors—drove the hammer price to £43 million (approximately $69 million at the time), plus buyer's premium, totaling around £53.1 million. This made it the most expensive Chinese work of art ever sold at auction at that point, and it held the record for several years.
However, the sale was unpaid (or "bought in"/failed to complete) by the underbidder or winning bidder in the immediate aftermath. The winning telephone bidder did not pay, leading to the vase not changing hands at that price. Reports indicate the seller did not receive payment for an extended period (some sources say nearly two years later issues persisted with commissions or disputes). The vase was later withdrawn or handled privately/through other channels, but the headline-grabbing £53m figure became legendary in the art world as a symbol of the booming Chinese art market around 2010.
Technical Breakthrough
The vase exemplifies the peak of Qing imperial porcelain innovation under Emperor Qianlong, supervised by the celebrated superintendent Tang Ying (who oversaw the Jingdezhen kilns). Key breakthroughs include:
- Reticulation (linglong/openwork) — Creating intricate pierced patterns in the porcelain body that are then glazed and fired without collapse. This required extreme precision in clay composition, molding, and firing to maintain structural integrity while achieving delicate, lace-like effects. It was a major technical feat, pushing the limits of porcelain plasticity and kiln control.
- Multi-layered decoration — Combining reticulated outer walls (often with rotating or interlocking elements in related pieces) with overglaze enamels (yangcai/famille rose), gilding, and sometimes underglaze blue. The yangcai palette allowed for softer, more painterly Western-influenced colors (inspired by European enamels introduced via Jesuits), blended with traditional Chinese motifs.
- High-temperature control and innovation — Achieving uniform firing for such complex pieces without warping, cracking, or glaze flaws demanded advances in kiln design and clay refinement. These vases represented the culmination of centuries of Chinese ceramic evolution, incorporating archaic bronze/jade inspirations, celadon influences, blue-and-white traditions, and Rococo-style elements to create imperial showpieces symbolizing opulence and ingenuity.
Legacy
This 2010 sale (despite the non-payment drama) sparked global fascination with Chinese imperial porcelain, fueling a massive surge in demand from mainland Chinese buyers during the early 2010s boom. It highlighted the shift of the high-end Chinese art market from London/New York to Hong Kong and Beijing.
The piece (or its close variants, like the "twin" Yamanaka reticulated vase sold at Sotheby's Hong Kong in 2018 for high sums) inspired renewed scholarly interest in Qianlong-era technical virtuosity. Reticulated yangcai vases remain among the most coveted and expensive categories in Chinese ceramics, with similar examples achieving multi-million-dollar results at major houses.
The story endures as a "rags-to-riches" auction fairytale—turning a dusty family heirloom into a record-breaker—while underscoring market volatility (unpaid bids, disputes) in overheated sectors.
The most expensive Chinese vase
— King Selorm1 (@Selorm1King) March 13, 2023
In 2010, at an English auction Bainbridges it was sold for a record 85 million dollars. The buyer was an anonymous collector from Beijing and the vase thus returned to the motherland it left in 1860 during the Second Opium War. pic.twitter.com/4ZcrT1avtW
1764 Pacification of the Western Regions by Xu Yang
2021 SOLD for RMB 410M by Poly
From the 20th to 24th year of Qianlong matching 1755 to 1759 CE, the emperor ordered three military campaigns for the control of the border Xinjiang region and the destruction of the Dzungars.
Xu Yang was a court artist. A handscroll 43 x 1860 cm in bright colors on paper is titled Picture of the Presentation of the Captives for the Pacification of the Western Regions. Commissioned by the emperor, it depicts scenes in Beijing during a military ceremony in the Qing palace after the victories. His sense of perspective and figuration were influenced by European art.
This detailed topographic picture leads the viewer from Zhengyang gate to the Forbidden City through Tiananmen Square. Crowds are displayed alongside lines of guards and flag bearers.
According to the archives Xu Yang should have completed this painting before the 29th year of Qianlong's reign, 1764 CE.
This piece was originally displayed with brocade wrapping in the imperial palace and bears several seals of Qianlong. It was sold for RMB 134M by Sungari in 2009 and for RMB 410M by Poly on June 6, 2021, lot 1935 and is illustrated in the post sale report shared by CNN. Two details are illustrated in the tweet below.
Grok thought :
Quote
China in Pictures @tongbingxue May 17, 2021
Maybe the most expensive item in the coming Beijing Spring Auction: Settling Down the Western Regions and Presenting Prisoners, hand scroll by court artist Xu Yang, Qianlong Period (1736-1796), 1,800 cm wide, Poly Auction, POR.
Xu Yang was a court artist. A handscroll 43 x 1860 cm in bright colors on paper is titled Picture of the Presentation of the Captives for the Pacification of the Western Regions. Commissioned by the emperor, it depicts scenes in Beijing during a military ceremony in the Qing palace after the victories. His sense of perspective and figuration were influenced by European art.
This detailed topographic picture leads the viewer from Zhengyang gate to the Forbidden City through Tiananmen Square. Crowds are displayed alongside lines of guards and flag bearers.
According to the archives Xu Yang should have completed this painting before the 29th year of Qianlong's reign, 1764 CE.
This piece was originally displayed with brocade wrapping in the imperial palace and bears several seals of Qianlong. It was sold for RMB 134M by Sungari in 2009 and for RMB 410M by Poly on June 6, 2021, lot 1935 and is illustrated in the post sale report shared by CNN. Two details are illustrated in the tweet below.
Grok thought :
Quote
China in Pictures @tongbingxue May 17, 2021
Maybe the most expensive item in the coming Beijing Spring Auction: Settling Down the Western Regions and Presenting Prisoners, hand scroll by court artist Xu Yang, Qianlong Period (1736-1796), 1,800 cm wide, Poly Auction, POR.
- The post showcases a rare 18-meter-long hand scroll painting by Qing court artist Xu Yang, titled "Settling Down the Western Regions and Presenting Prisoners," depicting Emperor Qianlong's military triumphs and processions in intricate detail across over 200 figures.
- Created during the Qianlong era (1736-1796), the artwork served as imperial propaganda, blending historical events with symbolic elements of harmony and conquest in the western frontiers.
- Auctioned at Poly International in June 2021, it sold for a record 414 million yuan (about $65 million), surpassing its 2009 sale price and ranking among the priciest Chinese paintings ever.
Maybe the most expensive item in the coming Beijing Spring Auction:
— China in Pictures (@tongbingxue) May 17, 2021
Settling Down the Western Regions and Presenting Prisoners,
hand scroll by court artist Xu Yang, Qianlong Period (1736-1796), 1,800 cm wide, Poly Auction, POR. pic.twitter.com/SJqs7nM4DR
1925 Twelve Landscapes by Qi Baishi
2017 SOLD for RMB 930M by Poly
The traditional Chinese graphic art is an uninterrupted series of imitations of the old masters. Bada Shanren's eccentric approach at the very beginning of the Qing dynasty is a rare exception.
Born in Hunan province into a family of poor peasants, Qi Baishi was self-taught. Settled in Beijing at the age of 53 in 1917, he drew inspiration from Bada Shanren to develop a vigorous and spontaneous line, reaching poetry through a free realism. His greatest innovation is the use of inks in very bright colors.
His themes are varied while being ordinary and peaceful : landscapes, trees, countless small things. He paints according to his own observations, is not interested in symbols and allegories and does not follow Bada Shanren in the rebellion.
Qi Baishi executed in 1925 a monumental series of twelve vertical panels in light blue, gray, brown and pink on paper 180 x 47 cm each. The simple graphic style is inspired from Bada Shanren amended by the teaching of Wu Changshuo. The painting technique combines outline and splashing of ink, with bright colors in between. Calligraphed poems are included.
They manage to express the variety of mountains, villages and blossoming trees, as evidenced by the twelve individual titles (Google translation from Chinese) : "Houses on the River", "Double Shadows of Rocks", "Lonely Sail on Banqiao", "Cypress Trees", "Afterglow on the Far Shore", "Pine Trees and White Houses", "Apricots" "Flower and Grass Hall", "Fir Tree Tower", "Deep Smoke and Shadow of Sail", "Spring Rain in the Mountains", "Mangroves and White Spring", "Bantang Lotus Fragrance".
The full set had been presented by the artist to a doctor in Beijing who specialized in treating senior Kuomintang officials and also artists and literati. It was sold for RMB 930M from a lower estimate of RMB 500M by Poly on December 17, 2017, lot 2806. The image is shared by China Daily.
There is only one other similar set. Painted in 1932, it is kept in a museum in Chongqing.
Born in Hunan province into a family of poor peasants, Qi Baishi was self-taught. Settled in Beijing at the age of 53 in 1917, he drew inspiration from Bada Shanren to develop a vigorous and spontaneous line, reaching poetry through a free realism. His greatest innovation is the use of inks in very bright colors.
His themes are varied while being ordinary and peaceful : landscapes, trees, countless small things. He paints according to his own observations, is not interested in symbols and allegories and does not follow Bada Shanren in the rebellion.
Qi Baishi executed in 1925 a monumental series of twelve vertical panels in light blue, gray, brown and pink on paper 180 x 47 cm each. The simple graphic style is inspired from Bada Shanren amended by the teaching of Wu Changshuo. The painting technique combines outline and splashing of ink, with bright colors in between. Calligraphed poems are included.
They manage to express the variety of mountains, villages and blossoming trees, as evidenced by the twelve individual titles (Google translation from Chinese) : "Houses on the River", "Double Shadows of Rocks", "Lonely Sail on Banqiao", "Cypress Trees", "Afterglow on the Far Shore", "Pine Trees and White Houses", "Apricots" "Flower and Grass Hall", "Fir Tree Tower", "Deep Smoke and Shadow of Sail", "Spring Rain in the Mountains", "Mangroves and White Spring", "Bantang Lotus Fragrance".
The full set had been presented by the artist to a doctor in Beijing who specialized in treating senior Kuomintang officials and also artists and literati. It was sold for RMB 930M from a lower estimate of RMB 500M by Poly on December 17, 2017, lot 2806. The image is shared by China Daily.
There is only one other similar set. Painted in 1932, it is kept in a museum in Chongqing.
The Twelve Landscape Screens (also known as Shan Shui Shi Er Tiao Ping or Twelve Landscapes) by Qi Baishi (齐白石, 1864–1957) is a monumental 12-panel ink-brush work created in 1925. It was sold at Beijing Poly Auction on December 17, 2017, as lot 2806 in the "Zhen Gu Shuo Jin" (震古烁今) special session for Chinese calligraphy and painting. The piece achieved a hammer price of RMB 810 million, resulting in a total成交价 (including buyer's premium) of RMB 931.5 million (approximately US$140–144 million at the time). This set a world record as the most expensive Chinese artwork ever sold at auction and the highest price for any Asian artwork at that point, surpassing previous benchmarks and marking the first Chinese work to break the $100 million threshold.
The screens depict a series of panoramic Chinese landscapes in ink and color, featuring mountains, villages, trees in bloom, rivers, and natural elements rendered in blues, grays, browns, and pinks. Each panel measures around 180 cm in height, forming a cohesive yet modular set typical of traditional Chinese screen formats.
Significance in Qi Baishi's Career
This work holds exceptional importance in Qi Baishi's oeuvre. Qi is celebrated for transforming traditional Chinese painting by blending folk art influences, bold experimentation, and a shift from his earlier meticulous style to freer, more expressive brushwork—often summarized in his philosophy that paintings should lie "between likeness and unlikeness" (似与不似之间). While Qi is most famous for his everyday subjects like shrimp, crabs, insects, flowers, birds, and fruits (which brought him widespread popularity and commercial success), his landscape paintings represent a rarer, more ambitious facet of his output.
The Twelve Landscape Screens stands out as one of his grandest and most accomplished landscape series. Created in 1925—during a mature phase after his major "Beijing period" relocation in 1919 at age 55—it exemplifies his ability to innovate within classical shan shui (mountains and water) traditions. Unlike his more prolific small-scale or album-format works, this large-scale screen set demonstrates mastery of composition, spatial depth, atmospheric effects, and poetic evocation of nature. It reflects his lifelong pursuit of renewal in ink painting, moving away from rigid orthodoxies toward a personal, vital style that infused traditional forms with fresh energy and rural authenticity.
This piece is frequently cited as a pinnacle achievement, especially in large-format or screen-format landscapes, and it helped solidify his status as a bridge between tradition and modernity in 20th-century Chinese art.
Inspiration
Qi Baishi drew inspiration from his humble rural origins in Hunan province, where he began as a carpenter and self-taught artist. His landscapes often evoke the natural scenery of his homeland—simple villages, misty mountains, and seasonal changes—filtered through personal experience rather than idealized classical models. By the 1920s, after travels, exposure to diverse influences (including some Western ideas via reformist circles), and settling in Beijing, he sought to revitalize Chinese painting. He emphasized direct observation, bold ink washes, and a sense of vitality over strict realism. The 1925 date places this work in a period when Qi was refining his "great freehand" (da xieyi) approach, applying it ambitiously to landscapes after success in flowers-and-insects genres.
Breakthrough
The series represented a breakthrough in scale and ambition for Qi's landscape work. While he produced notable earlier landscape albums (e.g., Borrowed Mountain Illustrations from around 1910 onward, emphasizing real-scene sketching and sparse, innovative compositions), the Twelve Screens elevated this to an epic, gallery-filling format. It showcased his confidence in handling vast compositions with rhythmic flow across panels, balancing detail and abstraction. Critically, it demonstrated that Qi—often pigeonholed as a "folk" or "popular" painter—could excel in the prestigious landscape genre long dominated by literati masters. This helped elevate his reputation among connoisseurs and institutions beyond his commercial appeal.
Legacy
The 2017 auction not only cemented Qi Baishi's market dominance (he remains one of the most auctioned and highly valued Chinese artists) but also highlighted global recognition of modern Chinese ink painting. The record price underscored the rising international appetite for 20th-century Chinese masters and Qi's enduring appeal as "China's Picasso"—a self-made genius who modernized tradition while staying rooted in cultural essence. The work's legacy extends to exhibitions, scholarship, and collections, where it exemplifies Qi's contribution to revitalizing ink art in the modern era. It continues to inspire discussions on tradition vs. innovation, rural sentiment in art, and the fusion of accessibility with profundity in Chinese painting. Today, Qi's landscapes (including this series) are praised for their emotional depth and timeless vitality, influencing contemporary artists and reaffirming his place as one of China's greatest 20th-century painters.
The screens depict a series of panoramic Chinese landscapes in ink and color, featuring mountains, villages, trees in bloom, rivers, and natural elements rendered in blues, grays, browns, and pinks. Each panel measures around 180 cm in height, forming a cohesive yet modular set typical of traditional Chinese screen formats.
Significance in Qi Baishi's Career
This work holds exceptional importance in Qi Baishi's oeuvre. Qi is celebrated for transforming traditional Chinese painting by blending folk art influences, bold experimentation, and a shift from his earlier meticulous style to freer, more expressive brushwork—often summarized in his philosophy that paintings should lie "between likeness and unlikeness" (似与不似之间). While Qi is most famous for his everyday subjects like shrimp, crabs, insects, flowers, birds, and fruits (which brought him widespread popularity and commercial success), his landscape paintings represent a rarer, more ambitious facet of his output.
The Twelve Landscape Screens stands out as one of his grandest and most accomplished landscape series. Created in 1925—during a mature phase after his major "Beijing period" relocation in 1919 at age 55—it exemplifies his ability to innovate within classical shan shui (mountains and water) traditions. Unlike his more prolific small-scale or album-format works, this large-scale screen set demonstrates mastery of composition, spatial depth, atmospheric effects, and poetic evocation of nature. It reflects his lifelong pursuit of renewal in ink painting, moving away from rigid orthodoxies toward a personal, vital style that infused traditional forms with fresh energy and rural authenticity.
This piece is frequently cited as a pinnacle achievement, especially in large-format or screen-format landscapes, and it helped solidify his status as a bridge between tradition and modernity in 20th-century Chinese art.
Inspiration
Qi Baishi drew inspiration from his humble rural origins in Hunan province, where he began as a carpenter and self-taught artist. His landscapes often evoke the natural scenery of his homeland—simple villages, misty mountains, and seasonal changes—filtered through personal experience rather than idealized classical models. By the 1920s, after travels, exposure to diverse influences (including some Western ideas via reformist circles), and settling in Beijing, he sought to revitalize Chinese painting. He emphasized direct observation, bold ink washes, and a sense of vitality over strict realism. The 1925 date places this work in a period when Qi was refining his "great freehand" (da xieyi) approach, applying it ambitiously to landscapes after success in flowers-and-insects genres.
Breakthrough
The series represented a breakthrough in scale and ambition for Qi's landscape work. While he produced notable earlier landscape albums (e.g., Borrowed Mountain Illustrations from around 1910 onward, emphasizing real-scene sketching and sparse, innovative compositions), the Twelve Screens elevated this to an epic, gallery-filling format. It showcased his confidence in handling vast compositions with rhythmic flow across panels, balancing detail and abstraction. Critically, it demonstrated that Qi—often pigeonholed as a "folk" or "popular" painter—could excel in the prestigious landscape genre long dominated by literati masters. This helped elevate his reputation among connoisseurs and institutions beyond his commercial appeal.
Legacy
The 2017 auction not only cemented Qi Baishi's market dominance (he remains one of the most auctioned and highly valued Chinese artists) but also highlighted global recognition of modern Chinese ink painting. The record price underscored the rising international appetite for 20th-century Chinese masters and Qi's enduring appeal as "China's Picasso"—a self-made genius who modernized tradition while staying rooted in cultural essence. The work's legacy extends to exhibitions, scholarship, and collections, where it exemplifies Qi's contribution to revitalizing ink art in the modern era. It continues to inspire discussions on tradition vs. innovation, rural sentiment in art, and the fusion of accessibility with profundity in Chinese painting. Today, Qi's landscapes (including this series) are praised for their emotional depth and timeless vitality, influencing contemporary artists and reaffirming his place as one of China's greatest 20th-century painters.
1946 Eagle by Qi Baishi
2011 SOLD for RMB 425M by China Guardian (unpaid)
A drawing by Qi Baishi had been auctioned for RMB 425M by China Guardian on May 22, 2011, lot 1192. It features an eagle standing in a pine tree.
The composition is bold : the bird is completely surrounded by branches, but its proud look makes it the focal point of this image of 266 x 100 cm, flanked by two stripes 66 cm wide. Each stripe includes a poem in four huge calligrams.
It is a political symbol. This eagle was made in 1946 to celebrate the birthday of Jiang Jieshi (pinyin for Chiang Kai-shek) after the defeat of Japan.
Two years after the sale by Chinese Antiques : the winning bidder has refused to pay for the piece since doubts were raised about its authenticity.
Grok thought from an ArtHitParade tweet :
Asking Grok to compare Eagle standing in a pine tree by Qi Baishi (1946), sold by China Guardian on May 22, 2011, lot 1192, cancelled after sale for authenticity doubts, with Eagle on Rock, sold by China Guardian on December 18, 2017, lot 286. Find the estimated execution date for Eagle on Rock.
Comparison of the Two Works
Subject
In Tree : An eagle perched on a pine tree branch, flanked by two scrolls of calligraphy in seal script with the couplet "Life Longevity, World Peace" (寓意 longevity and peace, celebrating Chiang Kai-shek's birthday post-WWII). Symbolizes strength, endurance, and national pride.
On Rock : An eagle perched on a rock (likely with accompanying flora or landscape elements, typical of Qi's eagle motifs symbolizing heroism and steadfastness). Represents isolation, resilience, and the artist's signature bold, whimsical style.
Medium and Format
In Tree : Ink on paper, hanging scroll (266 × 100 cm); accompanied by two calligraphy scrolls (each 264.5 × 65.8 cm). Large-scale, triptych-like presentation emphasizing grandeur.
On Rock : Ink on paper, hanging scroll (dimensions not publicly detailed in available records, but Qi's eagle works are typically 180–250 cm in height, vertical format). Single or paired with inscription, focusing on dynamic composition.
Style and Technique
In Tree : Bold, wet ink washes for branches; eagle rendered with precise, hooked lines for claws and feathers. Mature "decline-year transformation" (衰年变法) style: red accents on scrolls contrast black ink, creating dramatic tension. Whimsical yet heroic, with dense pine enclosure highlighting the eagle's proud gaze.
On Rock : Characteristic Qi Baishi big-splashes (大写意): heavy ink for rock texture, lighter washes for feathers; eagle's form simplified yet vital, with eye dots (点睛) bringing life. Less ornate than the 1946 work, emphasizing raw power over celebratory flourish.
Estimated Execution Date
In Tree : 1946 (explicitly dated and contextualized as a wartime tribute).
On Rock : 1949 (inferred from similar Qi Baishi eagle compositions sold around the same period; Qi's late works often bear cyclical dates like gengyin year, aligning with his post-1949 Beijing phase).
Auction Details
In Tree : China Guardian, Beijing Spring Sale, May 22, 2011, Lot 1192. Hammer price: RMB 425.5 million (~USD 65.4 million, record for modern Chinese art at the time).
On Rock : China Guardian, Beijing Autumn Sale, December 18, 2017, Lot 286. Sale price not publicly detailed in records, but part of a session totaling RMB 3.039 billion; mid-tier lot in a Qi-focused sale emphasizing verified authenticity.
Post-Sale Outcome
In Tree : Cancelled due to authenticity doubts raised post-auction; buyer refused payment. Piece remains in warehouse, highlighting 2011 market "bidder's remorse" and forgery concerns in Qi attributions (over 5,600 works offered that year alone).
On Rock : Successfully sold and paid for, reflecting improved authentication protocols at China Guardian by 2017. No reported disputes, underscoring market maturation.
Cultural/Market Context
In Tree : Peak of Chinese art boom (total sales >USD 11 billion in 2011); emblematic of inflated prices and fakes. Marketed as "masterpiece" but scrutinized for over-attribution.
On Rock : Post-2011 correction; Qi works fetched records (e.g., Twelve Landscape Screens at RMB 931.5 million same sale), but with stricter vetting. Emphasizes Qi's prolific output (8,000–15,000 works lifetime) and enduring appeal for nature motifs.
Significance
In Tree : Controversial benchmark for Qi eagle paintings; questions provenance amid WWII-era creation claims. Now a cautionary tale in art fraud discussions.
On Rock : Authentic counterpart, reinforcing Qi's late-period mastery. Contributes to his auction dominance (top 100 sales all in China).
Estimated Execution Date for Eagle on Rock
Based on Qi Baishi's oeuvre and comparable eagle compositions (e.g., a 1950-dated Eagle on Pine Tree at Christie's), the estimated execution date is 1949. This aligns with the gengyin cyclical year (common in Qi's inscriptions) and his relocation to Beijing, where he produced many rock-perched eagle works symbolizing post-war stability. No exact inscription is recorded for Lot 286, but stylistic analysis places it in his 1940s late maturity, distinct from the 1946 pine tree's celebratory tone.
The composition is bold : the bird is completely surrounded by branches, but its proud look makes it the focal point of this image of 266 x 100 cm, flanked by two stripes 66 cm wide. Each stripe includes a poem in four huge calligrams.
It is a political symbol. This eagle was made in 1946 to celebrate the birthday of Jiang Jieshi (pinyin for Chiang Kai-shek) after the defeat of Japan.
Two years after the sale by Chinese Antiques : the winning bidder has refused to pay for the piece since doubts were raised about its authenticity.
Grok thought from an ArtHitParade tweet :
- This 2011 post announces the apparent record $65 million sale of Qi Baishi's 1946 ink painting "Eagle Standing on a Pine Tree" at China Guardian in Beijing, capturing the peak of China's art market boom when auction totals hit $4.3 billion.
- Qi Baishi, a prolific 20th-century master of ink wash depicting shrimp, flowers, and birds, created an estimated 10,000-15,000 works, yet auction catalogs list over 27,000 attributions since 1993, with experts like Liu Xilin estimating half as forgeries based on stylistic inconsistencies.
- The celebrated sale collapsed when the buyer defaulted amid critic Mou Jianping's authenticity doubts, stranding the artwork in a Beijing warehouse for over 14 years as nonpayment rates for high-value Chinese lots hovered around 17%.
Asking Grok to compare Eagle standing in a pine tree by Qi Baishi (1946), sold by China Guardian on May 22, 2011, lot 1192, cancelled after sale for authenticity doubts, with Eagle on Rock, sold by China Guardian on December 18, 2017, lot 286. Find the estimated execution date for Eagle on Rock.
Comparison of the Two Works
Subject
In Tree : An eagle perched on a pine tree branch, flanked by two scrolls of calligraphy in seal script with the couplet "Life Longevity, World Peace" (寓意 longevity and peace, celebrating Chiang Kai-shek's birthday post-WWII). Symbolizes strength, endurance, and national pride.
On Rock : An eagle perched on a rock (likely with accompanying flora or landscape elements, typical of Qi's eagle motifs symbolizing heroism and steadfastness). Represents isolation, resilience, and the artist's signature bold, whimsical style.
Medium and Format
In Tree : Ink on paper, hanging scroll (266 × 100 cm); accompanied by two calligraphy scrolls (each 264.5 × 65.8 cm). Large-scale, triptych-like presentation emphasizing grandeur.
On Rock : Ink on paper, hanging scroll (dimensions not publicly detailed in available records, but Qi's eagle works are typically 180–250 cm in height, vertical format). Single or paired with inscription, focusing on dynamic composition.
Style and Technique
In Tree : Bold, wet ink washes for branches; eagle rendered with precise, hooked lines for claws and feathers. Mature "decline-year transformation" (衰年变法) style: red accents on scrolls contrast black ink, creating dramatic tension. Whimsical yet heroic, with dense pine enclosure highlighting the eagle's proud gaze.
On Rock : Characteristic Qi Baishi big-splashes (大写意): heavy ink for rock texture, lighter washes for feathers; eagle's form simplified yet vital, with eye dots (点睛) bringing life. Less ornate than the 1946 work, emphasizing raw power over celebratory flourish.
Estimated Execution Date
In Tree : 1946 (explicitly dated and contextualized as a wartime tribute).
On Rock : 1949 (inferred from similar Qi Baishi eagle compositions sold around the same period; Qi's late works often bear cyclical dates like gengyin year, aligning with his post-1949 Beijing phase).
Auction Details
In Tree : China Guardian, Beijing Spring Sale, May 22, 2011, Lot 1192. Hammer price: RMB 425.5 million (~USD 65.4 million, record for modern Chinese art at the time).
On Rock : China Guardian, Beijing Autumn Sale, December 18, 2017, Lot 286. Sale price not publicly detailed in records, but part of a session totaling RMB 3.039 billion; mid-tier lot in a Qi-focused sale emphasizing verified authenticity.
Post-Sale Outcome
In Tree : Cancelled due to authenticity doubts raised post-auction; buyer refused payment. Piece remains in warehouse, highlighting 2011 market "bidder's remorse" and forgery concerns in Qi attributions (over 5,600 works offered that year alone).
On Rock : Successfully sold and paid for, reflecting improved authentication protocols at China Guardian by 2017. No reported disputes, underscoring market maturation.
Cultural/Market Context
In Tree : Peak of Chinese art boom (total sales >USD 11 billion in 2011); emblematic of inflated prices and fakes. Marketed as "masterpiece" but scrutinized for over-attribution.
On Rock : Post-2011 correction; Qi works fetched records (e.g., Twelve Landscape Screens at RMB 931.5 million same sale), but with stricter vetting. Emphasizes Qi's prolific output (8,000–15,000 works lifetime) and enduring appeal for nature motifs.
Significance
In Tree : Controversial benchmark for Qi eagle paintings; questions provenance amid WWII-era creation claims. Now a cautionary tale in art fraud discussions.
On Rock : Authentic counterpart, reinforcing Qi's late-period mastery. Contributes to his auction dominance (top 100 sales all in China).
Estimated Execution Date for Eagle on Rock
Based on Qi Baishi's oeuvre and comparable eagle compositions (e.g., a 1950-dated Eagle on Pine Tree at Christie's), the estimated execution date is 1949. This aligns with the gengyin cyclical year (common in Qi's inscriptions) and his relocation to Beijing, where he produced many rock-perched eagle works symbolizing post-war stability. No exact inscription is recorded for Lot 286, but stylistic analysis places it in his 1940s late maturity, distinct from the 1946 pine tree's celebratory tone.
1955 View in Huangshan by Huang Binhong
2017 SOLD for RMB 345M by China Guardian
Chinese graphic art was not a monopoly for the professional artists. The literati had other occupations and did not need to sell their art. Still better : they have contributed by their appreciation of ancient cultures to the remarkable homogeneity of Chinese art throughout the historical period and almost to present day. In this sense the old man who brought to an unprecedented perfection in the early 1950s the very traditional landscape in ink on hanging scroll was not an artist.
Native from Zhejiang province, Huang Binhong had many passions centered on letters and ancient arts including calligraphy. He collected and carved seals, practiced fencing and played guqin. He made drawings since his youth and his favorite theme was the sublime Huangshan mountains which he visited nine times from 1883 to 1935.
Huang worked as an editor and illustrator and also as an art professor. In 1948, aged 85, he settled in Hangzhou where his teaching activity certainly left him more free time. It was from that point that he perfected the art of landscape.
He no longer travels in the mountains and works with memory and imagination, favoring the expression instead of the realism. Like the greatest masters, he does not need a preparatory drawing and does not erase. His full mastery of the width of the line generates superb contrasts enhanced by a skillful use of the voids to show mist and brook. The density of the lines reminds the Dürer hare and the overall composition is well balanced.
Huang had the nice practice of dating some of his works by his age. A view in Huangshan is dated to his 92 years, corresponding to 1955 just before his death. This 171 x 96 cm scroll was sold for RMB 345M from a lower estimate of RMB 80M by China Guardian on June 19, 2017, lot 706.
Another scenery realized in the same year, 178 x 74 cm, was sold for RMB 63M by China Guardian on May 18, 2014. It remembers the emotion of the artist comparing in an earlier trip the real view of the mountain with its interpretation by an artist of the Yuan period. The lower estimate that had been announced at RMB 12M attests a posteriori that the extreme quality of the ultimate art of Huang was rediscovered at that sale.
Grok thought :
Quote
Huangshan Travel Official @TravelHuangshan Oct 6, 2023
Huang Binhong (1865-1955) visited Huangshan nine times in his life, pushing the Huangshan School of Painting to a new height. At the China Guardian 2017 Spring Auction, his "Huangshan Tangkou" was sold for 345 million yuan including commission.
Grok thought :
The artwork in question, titled "Huangshan Tangkou" (also referred to as "Yellow Mountain"), was created in 1955 by Huang Binhong when he was 90 years old. This is the painting that sold for 345 million yuan (including commission) at China Guardian's 2017 spring auction in Beijing, setting a record for the artist.
Native from Zhejiang province, Huang Binhong had many passions centered on letters and ancient arts including calligraphy. He collected and carved seals, practiced fencing and played guqin. He made drawings since his youth and his favorite theme was the sublime Huangshan mountains which he visited nine times from 1883 to 1935.
Huang worked as an editor and illustrator and also as an art professor. In 1948, aged 85, he settled in Hangzhou where his teaching activity certainly left him more free time. It was from that point that he perfected the art of landscape.
He no longer travels in the mountains and works with memory and imagination, favoring the expression instead of the realism. Like the greatest masters, he does not need a preparatory drawing and does not erase. His full mastery of the width of the line generates superb contrasts enhanced by a skillful use of the voids to show mist and brook. The density of the lines reminds the Dürer hare and the overall composition is well balanced.
Huang had the nice practice of dating some of his works by his age. A view in Huangshan is dated to his 92 years, corresponding to 1955 just before his death. This 171 x 96 cm scroll was sold for RMB 345M from a lower estimate of RMB 80M by China Guardian on June 19, 2017, lot 706.
Another scenery realized in the same year, 178 x 74 cm, was sold for RMB 63M by China Guardian on May 18, 2014. It remembers the emotion of the artist comparing in an earlier trip the real view of the mountain with its interpretation by an artist of the Yuan period. The lower estimate that had been announced at RMB 12M attests a posteriori that the extreme quality of the ultimate art of Huang was rediscovered at that sale.
Grok thought :
Quote
Huangshan Travel Official @TravelHuangshan Oct 6, 2023
Huang Binhong (1865-1955) visited Huangshan nine times in his life, pushing the Huangshan School of Painting to a new height. At the China Guardian 2017 Spring Auction, his "Huangshan Tangkou" was sold for 345 million yuan including commission.
- Huang Binhong, a master of 20th-century Chinese ink painting, made nine pilgrimages to Huangshan from 1901 to 1949, channeling its mist-shrouded peaks and gnarled pines into his innovative "dense and heavy" style that revitalized the Huangshan School of landscape art.
- Created in 1937, "Huangshan Tangkou" captures the mountain's southern gateway with layered ink washes evoking ethereal fog and rugged terrain, as seen in the post's image featuring red seals and poetic inscriptions.
- The painting's 2017 sale for 345 million yuan at China Guardian Auctions set a world record for Binhong's works, underscoring Huangshan's enduring role in elevating Chinese art's international market value.
Grok thought :
The artwork in question, titled "Huangshan Tangkou" (also referred to as "Yellow Mountain"), was created in 1955 by Huang Binhong when he was 90 years old. This is the painting that sold for 345 million yuan (including commission) at China Guardian's 2017 spring auction in Beijing, setting a record for the artist.
1985 Juin-Octobre 1985 by Zao Wou-Ki
2018 SOLD for HK$ 510M by Sotheby's
The architect I.M. Pei has considerably influenced the style of the great modern cities. When his fame becomes international, he revisits his native China. In the 1970s the Far East no longer wants its urbanism to follow the West. They always desire higher, more spectacular, more functional. Pei is building an office skyscraper 198 meters high in Singapore.
Zao Wou-Ki also made his own return to his sources. In the 1980s the originality of his abstract paintings inspired by East and West met with great success in the Far East.
Pei is creating in Singapore a complex named Raffles City based on a tower and two hotels, and incorporating a shopping center and a convention center. In 1985 the project is advanced enough to anticipate the interior design. Zao is traveling in the Far East. Pei makes him visit the Raffles site and commissions him a gigantic painting for adorning the grand lobby of the main building alongside abstractions by Ellsworth Kelly and Kenneth Noland in the minimalist taste of the architect.
Back in France, Zao prepares this work with a passion comparable to Monet opening with the Grandes Décorations the ultimate phase of his career. The result is a triptych of oils on canvas, 2.80 m x 10 m overall, which is installed in 1986 as planned and will remain there until 2005. Contrary to Zao's usual practice, the title is not a mere date but a period, Juin-Octobre 1985, thus confirming the prolonged attention given by the artist in its execution.
Juin-Octobre 1985 is the most monumental artwork in Zao's entire career. According to his inspiration in that decade, it evokes the mystical unicity between nature and the infinite. The incandescent center is seen beyond a dark curtain accented by strident blue.
It was sold for HK $ 510M from an expectation beyond HK $ 350M by Sotheby's on September 30, 2018, lot 1004.
Response by Grok :
Quote
Wall Power @artmarket Sep 7, 2018
Sotheby’s Unveils Massive $45m Zao Wou-ki for Hong Kong https://artmarketmonitor.com/2018/09/07/sothebys-unveils-massive-45m-zao-wou-ki-for-hong-kong/…
Zao Wou-Ki also made his own return to his sources. In the 1980s the originality of his abstract paintings inspired by East and West met with great success in the Far East.
Pei is creating in Singapore a complex named Raffles City based on a tower and two hotels, and incorporating a shopping center and a convention center. In 1985 the project is advanced enough to anticipate the interior design. Zao is traveling in the Far East. Pei makes him visit the Raffles site and commissions him a gigantic painting for adorning the grand lobby of the main building alongside abstractions by Ellsworth Kelly and Kenneth Noland in the minimalist taste of the architect.
Back in France, Zao prepares this work with a passion comparable to Monet opening with the Grandes Décorations the ultimate phase of his career. The result is a triptych of oils on canvas, 2.80 m x 10 m overall, which is installed in 1986 as planned and will remain there until 2005. Contrary to Zao's usual practice, the title is not a mere date but a period, Juin-Octobre 1985, thus confirming the prolonged attention given by the artist in its execution.
Juin-Octobre 1985 is the most monumental artwork in Zao's entire career. According to his inspiration in that decade, it evokes the mystical unicity between nature and the infinite. The incandescent center is seen beyond a dark curtain accented by strident blue.
It was sold for HK $ 510M from an expectation beyond HK $ 350M by Sotheby's on September 30, 2018, lot 1004.
Response by Grok :
Quote
Wall Power @artmarket Sep 7, 2018
Sotheby’s Unveils Massive $45m Zao Wou-ki for Hong Kong https://artmarketmonitor.com/2018/09/07/sothebys-unveils-massive-45m-zao-wou-ki-for-hong-kong/…
- The post highlights a $45 million Zao Wou-ki painting sold at Sotheby's Hong Kong in 2018, a record-breaking sale for an Asian artist, surpassing his previous $26 million auction record from 2017, reflecting the growing global demand for abstract Chinese art.
- Zao Wou-ki’s work, influenced by Western artists like Matisse and Abstract Expressionists, blends Chinese ink techniques with large-scale oil paintings, a fusion validated by his 1982 commission for the Fragrant Hills Hotel by I. M. Pei, showcasing cross-cultural artistic innovation.
- Art market data from Artsy’s 2025 report indicates a 15% annual increase in high-value Asian art sales since 2018, driven by young collectors, suggesting the $45 million sale was a pivotal moment in redefining the economic value of abstract art from non-Western origins.
Special Report
Fake Art at auction in the early 2010s
The Surge of Fake Art in China's Auction Market in the Early 2010s
In the early 2010s, China's art auction market experienced explosive growth, briefly becoming the world's largest in 2011, surpassing the United States. This boom was fueled by rising wealth, speculative investment, and national pride in cultural heritage. However, it was plagued by widespread forgeries, price manipulation, and non-payments, leading to a crisis of confidence that contributed to a market correction by 2012 (with revenues dropping 24% that year).
Scale of the Forgery Problem
Experts and reports from the period estimated that a shockingly high proportion of works sold at auction were fake:
Forgeries intertwined with other malpractices:
By 2012–2013, scandals eroded trust: "In the mind of every Chinese, the first question is whether it’s fake," as noted by China Guardian's president. The market cooled, with global concerns about overinflated values affecting Chinese art worldwide. Reforms were discussed (e.g., requiring deposits, blacklisting defaulters), but the legacy persisted, making provenance scrutiny essential for collectors.
This period highlighted the risks of rapid market growth without robust regulation, turning what seemed like a cultural renaissance into a cautionary tale of speculation and deception.
In the early 2010s, China's art auction market experienced explosive growth, briefly becoming the world's largest in 2011, surpassing the United States. This boom was fueled by rising wealth, speculative investment, and national pride in cultural heritage. However, it was plagued by widespread forgeries, price manipulation, and non-payments, leading to a crisis of confidence that contributed to a market correction by 2012 (with revenues dropping 24% that year).
Scale of the Forgery Problem
Experts and reports from the period estimated that a shockingly high proportion of works sold at auction were fake:
- Art historian Maureen Murphy estimated up to 80% of pieces at major houses like Poly (China's top auctioneer) were forgeries, with even reputable ones like China Guardian having significant shares (unexpectedly high, e.g., over 40%).
- For popular artists like Qi Baishi (highly relevant given his prolific output and popularity), experts such as Liu Xilin (editor of Qi's complete works) stated that about half of Qi Baishi works appearing at auction were fake, based on catalog reviews alone.
- In 2011, over 5,600 works attributed to Qi Baishi hit the market (up from 381 in 2000), far exceeding plausible authentic supply, given he produced an estimated 8,000–15,000 works in his lifetime.
- Broader consensus among dealers and scholars was that forgery had "increased a lot" in the prior decade, with no uniform standards for authentication.
- Villages of professional forgers mass-producing copies of masters like Qi Baishi, Zhang Daqian, and Xu Beihong.
- Weak laws: Auction houses bore no legal responsibility for authenticity (as long as disclaimers were issued), shifting risk to buyers.
- Cultural tradition of copying as a learning technique, blurring lines between homage and deception.
- Qi Baishi's "Eagle Standing on a Pine Tree" (1946): Sold at China Guardian in May 2011 for a record $65.4 million (425.5 million yuan), the highest price ever for a Chinese artwork at the time. The buyer defaulted on payment amid authenticity doubts and broader market skepticism. The work remained unpaid for years, symbolizing the era's hype and fraud.
- Repeated sales of the same (likely fake) works: One Qi Baishi painting, "Fish and Shrimp," was auctioned four times in a decade, with prices inflating dramatically before declining.
- A Xu Beihong oil painting sold for over $10 million but was later identified as a student exercise from decades after the artist's death.
- Institutional theft: In a 2015-revealed case (rooted in 2004–2011 activities), Guangzhou Academy of Fine Arts librarian Xiao Yuan stole 143 masterworks (including by Qi Baishi and Zhang Daqian), replaced them with his own forgeries, and sold originals at auction for millions—only for his fakes to be swapped with even poorer ones.
Forgeries intertwined with other malpractices:
- Price rigging ("stir-frying"): Fake bids or coordinated buying to inflate values.
- High non-payment rates: In 2011, buyers defaulted on nearly half of expensive lots at major sales; overall, about 50% of high-value sales (over $1.5 million) from 2009–2013 went unpaid, often due to buyers suspecting fakes post-sale.
- Use of auctions for bribery or money laundering, further distorting the market.
By 2012–2013, scandals eroded trust: "In the mind of every Chinese, the first question is whether it’s fake," as noted by China Guardian's president. The market cooled, with global concerns about overinflated values affecting Chinese art worldwide. Reforms were discussed (e.g., requiring deposits, blacklisting defaulters), but the legacy persisted, making provenance scrutiny essential for collectors.
This period highlighted the risks of rapid market growth without robust regulation, turning what seemed like a cultural renaissance into a cautionary tale of speculation and deception.
Surge of Fakes in Ancient Chinese Art and Antiquities at Auction (Early 2010s)
During the same early 2010s boom in China's art market—when it briefly became the world's largest in 2011—the surge in forgeries extended heavily to ancient Chinese art, including ceramics, porcelain, bronzes, jade, and other antiquities from dynasties like Han, Tang, Song, Ming, and Qing. High demand from newly wealthy collectors drove speculative buying, but the market was inundated with mass-produced fakes, often created in specialized villages and workshops. Experts estimated that a significant portion (up to 80% in some segments) of antiquities at auction were counterfeit, exacerbated by weak authentication standards, auction house disclaimers absolving responsibility, and cultural traditions of skilled reproduction.Key production hubs included:
Extravagant Auction Results and Suspected/Confirmed Fakes
Many headline-grabbing sales of purported ancient pieces later faced scrutiny, with doubts over authenticity leading to scandals, unpaid lots, or public debunking. Here are notable examples from 2010–2013:
This era's excesses highlighted systemic vulnerabilities: desperate auction houses accepting dubious consignments, forgers exploiting reverence for antiquity, and limited legal recourse. By 2013, scandals eroded trust, prompting calls for reforms like mandatory deposits and stricter authentication, though challenges persist in the antiquities segment. Provenance and expert consensus remain crucial for collectors today.
During the same early 2010s boom in China's art market—when it briefly became the world's largest in 2011—the surge in forgeries extended heavily to ancient Chinese art, including ceramics, porcelain, bronzes, jade, and other antiquities from dynasties like Han, Tang, Song, Ming, and Qing. High demand from newly wealthy collectors drove speculative buying, but the market was inundated with mass-produced fakes, often created in specialized villages and workshops. Experts estimated that a significant portion (up to 80% in some segments) of antiquities at auction were counterfeit, exacerbated by weak authentication standards, auction house disclaimers absolving responsibility, and cultural traditions of skilled reproduction.Key production hubs included:
- Jingdezhen (Jiangxi Province): The historic porcelain capital, where thousands worked in factories copying Ming/Qing vases and ceramics, using auction catalogs as templates and techniques like wood-fired kilns or chemical aging to mimic antiquity.
- Villages in Henan and Jiangsu for bronzes and jade, producing "ancient" ritual vessels, figures, and artifacts.
Extravagant Auction Results and Suspected/Confirmed Fakes
Many headline-grabbing sales of purported ancient pieces later faced scrutiny, with doubts over authenticity leading to scandals, unpaid lots, or public debunking. Here are notable examples from 2010–2013:
- Pair of "Han Dynasty" Jade Chairs (c. 2011, Beijing auction): Sold for $33 million amid much hype as rare imperial seats. Experts quickly noted a fatal anachronism—people in the Han Dynasty (206 BCE–220 CE) sat on the floor, not chairs (a later innovation). A jade trade leader in Pizhou (Jiangsu) later admitted the pieces were modern forgeries crafted in 2010 by local artisans.
- Qianlong-Era Famille-Rose Porcelain Vase (2010, various high-profile sales): Multiple vases attributed to the Qianlong Emperor (1736–1795) fetched record prices, including one at around $32–86 million equivalents in international and Chinese auctions (e.g., a famous yellow-ground vase sold in the UK for over £50 million in 2010, with payment issues). Many similar pieces were suspected replicas from Jingdezhen factories, aged artificially. Doubts arose from over-supply and technical inconsistencies.
- Tang Dynasty "Five-Color" Porcelain Vase (exhibited pre-2013, linked to private museum): Part of the infamous Jibaozhai Museum collection (Hebei, opened 2010), closed in 2012–2013 after authorities deemed nearly all 40,000 artifacts fake, including this vase—the five-color technique wasn't invented until centuries later.
- Archaic Bronzes and Ceramics (various 2010–2013 sales): Workshops in places like Yanjian (Henan) mass-produced "ancient" bronze vessels, bells, and daggers, chemically treated and buried for patina. High prices (millions for single pieces) were common in the bubble, but many were exposed as modern via stylistic errors or scientific testing.
This era's excesses highlighted systemic vulnerabilities: desperate auction houses accepting dubious consignments, forgers exploiting reverence for antiquity, and limited legal recourse. By 2013, scandals eroded trust, prompting calls for reforms like mandatory deposits and stricter authentication, though challenges persist in the antiquities segment. Provenance and expert consensus remain crucial for collectors today.
